Holy Lance Maduro is on top of my list right now. With the L40, Cain F, el triunfafor OR and tat black close behind. I have yet to try the Casa Fuente, My Father, OpusX or the Viaje lanceros yet. I'm sure they will rank up there, especially the Casa
Here are my favorites although there may be others out there or something that I'm forgetting:
* El Triunfador Original Blend (brown label)
* Illusione ~ hl ~
* Casa Fuente
The Cain F's are what really got me started on this size and the lancero quickly became my favorite. Looks like I have a lot to try, as i have not had many that have been listed thus far. I did just pick up some Trini Fundadores that I have been dying to try. Always down for any box splits of lance's
Tatuaje NHC Capa Especial (More of a Londsdale)
Cain F Lancero
Graycliff Espresso Elegante
Don Carlos Lancero
Tatuaje Black Label Petite Lancero (OR)
Oliva V Lancero
Opus X Petite Lancero
DPG "Puff n Stuff" Blue Label (2007)
The Tatuaje Black started out within the first few puffs as one of the worst cigars ever, but then turned into one of the best for me. Smoke at least one of them a week. My Father #4 is awesome and the LFD air bender lancero for when I want a smack to the face.