Cigar Aficionado Top 25

[MattSRoss81]

Edit: ROMEO got #3, there is my head scratcher, lol.

You and me both! Didn't enjoy that stick at all

 

[tylernim]

Going back to yesterday, I'm really ok with the Nat Sherman. It's got great value. It's aroma is wonderful. Not the MOST complex, but a good smoke.

Better go get your LATs while you can!

 

[Reeve11]

I'm guessing Oliva Series V Meliano or La Palina El Diario

Dan

 

[zama80]

I smoked a Romeo and it was pretty good. But not that damn good. That one is a head scratched for me as we'll.

 

[BrandonP]

I think #1 will be the Melanio. LAT56 will end up being #11 or #12 I think.

 

[CigarGavin]

I think #1 will be the Melanio. LAT56 will end up being #11 or #12 I think.

+1 agreed after seeing the next list this morning

 

[pbibby]

I think #1 will be the Melanio. LAT56 will end up being #11 or #12 I think.

+1 agreed after seeing the next list this morning

This for sure!

Sent from my SCH-R530U using Tapatalk 2

 

[willzbar]

Edit: ROMEO got #3, there is my head scratcher, lol.

You and me both! Didn't enjoy that stick at all

I did think it was good compared to other NC R&J but like the Monty epic didn't think they are top 25 cigars

 

[ciggy]

This list always cracks me up. In my opinion Pete, Drew, and Padron should always make the top ten for sure. I also think RomaCraft and Crowned Heads should have been in the Top as well as they both were great smokes...Also have to give props to Tres Reynas brand.

 

[Slidzero]

I think if CA is going to award the top spot to a new company it will be Crowned heads. Four Kicks as the Dark Horse #1!

 

[MoJo]

It is looking like the LAT has a decent shot at number 1, since the Cohiba is number 2...

agreed

 

[vivalanation734]

Lol Romeo is #3?

And their continued lack of credibility is confirmed.

 

[vivalanation734]

I think #1 will be the Melanio. LAT56 will end up being #11 or #12 I think.

Melanio wasn't good IMHO. The regular V is far superior. I'm pulling for LAT or anything from Dion.

 

[Reeve11]

I think #1 will be the Melanio. LAT56 will end up being #11 or #12 I think.

Melanio wasn't good IMHO. The regular V is far superior. I'm pulling for LAT or anything from Dion.

My guess wasn't based on what I think should be number 1. Just what I think they will pick.

Dan

 

[Alwayslit]

Meh, just another list.

 

[Dread]

LFD still isnt represented up there either, so thats another possible option. La Palina Goldie too.

 

[HTML5 Gordon]

Lol Romeo is #3?

And their continued lack of credibility is confirmed.

Come on, surely it has nothing do to with these full page Romeo ads in the last several issues of CA (with a 2 page spread in the 20th anniv issue). :scratchhe

I also can't believe that the Romeo got a 92 rating, but like we say, tastes are subjective.

 

[Reeve11]

Meh, just another list.

I think the lists are fun to read at this time of year.

Also the manufacturers sure view them important enough judging by the amount of thank you posts/retweets/facebook status updates I've seen in the last few weeks.

to each their own, we all know it comes down to individual taste mostly..

/derail off

Dan

 

[jayro75]

Lol Romeo is #3?

And their continued lack of credibility is confirmed.

Come on, surely it has nothing do to with these full page Romeo ads in the last several issues of CA (with a 2 page spread in the 20th anniv issue). :scratchhe

I also can't believe that the Romeo got a 92 rating, but like we say, tastes are subjective.

Which explains the top 3 finish for Dion, Viaje, and of course the ratings for anything out of Cuba.

 

[BSBONO]

I actually enjoyed the Romeo and believe me I had low expectations. Number 3 worthy for me not but top 15 maybe. I think this is CA recognizing a mass produced company finally getting it right.