How many days has it been since you sent payment?
It has only been 4 days; I sent payment Wednesday and was told that he would try to ship Thursday; I didn't hear anything or get any tracking info Thursday so I sent a pm Friday asking if he got held up or something, I didn't get a response; sent another pm Saturday again no response, sent a third pm still nothing, I did figure I'd give it a week but wasn't sure what I should do if I still get nothing..
Four days really isn't a long time. He might have already sent them, and just didn't give you any tracking info. Although communication is a key factor when involved in a transaction, the lack of a response could be due to a vacation or an emergency as many have stated. Hell, they might be in your mailbox tomorrow. If you haven't received your cigars or heard back from him in a few days, by all means contact a mod, but until then I'd just assume they are on their way. Just my two pennies.