Somehow, I've managed to miss this thread until now.
Best places are local record shops, flea markets, and estate sales.
I also have had really good luck with particular shops on Instagram believe it or not. For example,
@vitaminvintagevinyl or
@indyrecordshop. They post vinyl for sale and include grades for the record and for the sleeve, and if you want it you just comment "BUY". I have found so many gems from these guys it's insane. And their grading and pricing are superb. (Both also have an Etsy store if you want to see their whole catalog for sale).
I'm a huge fan of
SMLXLvinyl.com. They sell all new records but they have some really good ones at great prices.
I actually find
Amazon's Vinyl page to be a great source. They have, as usual, everything and even have the colored vinyl, heavier gram weights, and picture discs available for the Albums that were pressed that way. And the best part is if there is a problem, let them know and they'll send you another one.
I freaking love Amazon!
Another location that works really well for bands that are still "up and coming" is to go to their website and purchase the vinyl they have for sale. Most of these bands end up getting their vinyl on Amazon but occasionally, you just have to go to the band's website. For example,
@Xingpao got me HOOKED on a band called St. Paul & the Broken Bones (
go listen to them right now if you haven't heard of them). After checking them out on YouTube (
favorite video of them here), I had to find out if they had vinyl available. Amazon had their 2nd album but not their first. One quick check on the band's website and boom, nabbed them both.
I have learned to absolutely avoid most big box retailers (Barnes & Noble) and smaller places like Vintage Exchange. They have the "all sales are final" rule which I understand but if you can't test out a record before buying then it seems like an unfair advantage for them. I've received 5 different albums from both locations and 7 of them ended up warped/scratched right out of the sleeve. Wasted purchases and they were overpriced.