I know Tom will agree with me, the Chaveta by PDR is a GREAT suggestion. From what I understand it runs about $5 but smokes like its two to three times the value, it is rich dark an oily but strangely medium bodied and the wrappers aren't died either. I remember allot of cocoa while smoking this cigar, I highly recommend it
Oliva Serie V, CAO La Traviata, Diesel Unholy Cocktail & Brickhouse are three good ones IMHO I know all of these have already been listed but I thought I would put them up also
Oliva V Lancero, Illusione 68, Padron x000, Diesel, Brickhouse, MOW Ruination, Los Blancos NINE, Hemingway Best Seller. Lots of good choices out there in that range.