Thanks Cigary...
So an update for everyone:
I managed to spend a little time at the LCDH in Jamaica. If you've never been to an LCDH it's worth going. If you've been to some already YMMV. As some of you have already said it is priced as you would expect an LCDH in a tourist area. For example a CoRo was $25.00 and a Partagas Aristocrat was $9.00. A down side is that it's selection appears to mainly be within the last two years. Possibly this is due to it being a new LCDH. The stock also seems fairly limited. For example they were out of CoLas, Sir Winstons, and a couple of other items I asked for. They didn't seem to have most of the Els and I saw no REs although their options there are fairly limited.
The salesman was semi-pushy. I ended up picking up 7 cigars for the remainder of the trip (Partagas Serie C No. 3 EL 2012, Partagas Salomon LCDH, Punch Punch, 2x Punch Royal Coronation w/ old band and tubo, Vegas Robaina Clasicos, and H. Upmann Magnum 50. Total $158) and he was really pushing for me to buy 10. He followed me around the humidor and anything I got near he would open up and stick it up to my nose then try to hand me one. We had a large pile of boxes by the time I finished. He did give me a couple glasses of Havana Club and threw in some butane I needed. I just didn't want 10 and being that I have so many at home there was absolutely no need for me to risk anything. Overall he was annoying but not as bad as I've probably made him sound.
Overall it was worth the trip for me (although I probably won't be back) but if you are able to visit LCDHs on a regular or even semi-regular basis this probably isn't worth your time.