Cigar Aficianado's 2009 top 25 coming in January

[bmony]

I hope this year they finally give some love to everybody's favorite cigar.....Swisher Sweet!

 

[kockroach]

Backwoods. Nuff said.

 

[Alwayslit]

Honorable mention to white owl.

 

[jmatkins]

I hope this year they finally give some love to everybody's favorite cigar.....Swisher Sweet!

I love that cherry smell

 

[whodeeni]

garcia y vegas English Corona's in the Dark Brown Plastic Tubo! :agreeclen

 

[BrandonJ]

garcia y vegas English Corona's in the Dark Brown Plastic Tubo! :agreeclen

I've got some ones in Crystal tubos for sale... Anyone, anyone?

 

[derfatdutchman]

Naw, I heard the white owl strawberry blunts had it all sewn up for cigar of the year!

 

[whodeeni]

$.01 cent brotha, + a coupon for FREE SHIPPING!

I'll even throw in

 

[njstone]

I think we'll see 2 Tats on the list at least (Havana VI and another ... Boris?), one of which will be in the Top Three if not the #1.

 

[BrooksW]

I think we'll see 2 Tats on the list at, one of which will be in the Top Three if not the #1.

Not gonna happen (tat #1 that is)...

I put the Padron 45th Maduro on THEIR list at number one...

La Traviata will be in the top 10...

~brooks

 

[ctaylor]

I think we'll see 2 Tats on the list at least (Havana VI and another ... Boris?), one of which will be in the Top Three if not the #1.

I agree there will be 2-3 tats in the top 25. My guess for the top 5 is Cohiba GR, LFD salomon, Padron 45th, Boris, and an Opus.

 

[tmoney2007]

The real question is, will they put another budget smoke above them all and throw the "value" card?

I need to go back and smoke another, but I don't really see the salomon in the top 5, but I think the 45th will be up there, which sucks, because everyone will go buy them then and I'll have to get my box sooner than I wanted to.

 

[ctaylor]

The real question is, will they put another budget smoke above them all and throw the "value" card?

I need to go back and smoke another, but I don't really see the salomon in the top 5, but I think the 45th will be up there, which sucks, because everyone will go buy them then and I'll have to get my box sooner than I wanted to.

No. I def don't think they will this year because of all the drama caused when they did it last year.
They have the Salomon rated at 95, it'll have to be up in the top 5, there is a partagas CC salomon I think they rated at 95 too. So there will prob be 2 salomons in top ten.

 

[njstone]

The real question is, will they put another budget smoke above them all and throw the "value" card?

I need to go back and smoke another, but I don't really see the salomon in the top 5, but I think the 45th will be up there, which sucks, because everyone will go buy them then and I'll have to get my box sooner than I wanted to.

2 budget smokes in the Top 10: Tatuaje Havana VI and CAO La Travaita

 

[hdroadglide]

won't find a monster or a black on that list. don't think pete ever gives them anything like that to rate.

 

[ciggy]

My dogs got a few out back they should give honorable mention too!! :hysterica

 

[hdroadglide]

My dogs got a few out back they should give honorable mention too!! :hysterica

if you bought a big ad for them, they'd be rated!

 

[SkinsFanLarry]

if you bought a big ad for them, they'd be rated!

....that's alway been the case with CA!

I would'nt be surprised to see the Brick House on that list too!

 

[WkndSmoker]

I hope Black and Milds make the ratings this year in the top 10, I have a small collection from a friend, I get offered to smoke a, "cigar," then it is off to my humidor we go. It is his way of asking for one of mine, so I have saved the cigars he gives me. I could unload those bad boys in trades when they make cigar of the year!

:halfgrinw

 

[ciggy]

Seriously, I bet the Oliva Series V Maduro 2009 ed makes the list and a Padron Anni!