I've only had one WOAM, and only one Anejo and it was the 46. I really loved both of these cigars, and it's tough to make a choice based on one experience. But I'd give the nod to the Anejo if pressed.
For me, the WOAM gets the vote! I've smoked every Anejo, and they just don't do it for me. The only Anejo I would buy on a consistent basis would be the 46, but I'd rather have a Hemi Mad.