Favorite Two H. Upmanns?-Votes Tallied.

[The Prince]

Okay, picking my top two vitola's In this range Is more difficult than the Bolivars. However, after much contemplation, I will have to state that the Super Coronas, and Sir Winstons are my top two favorites. What's yours?


Votes Tallied.

Sir Winston: 5
Super Corona: 3
Magnum 46: 11
Monarcas: 4
No. 2: 4
No. 4: 1
Puritos (?): 1
Especiales: 1
Petit Coronas: 1

 

[allanf]

I've only had the mags. but as has been stated on other posts, i'm mainly a fan of larger cigars....so I'll have to give those a try sometime...

 

[The Prince]

You should try the Sir Winston. If not the, then one of the consumate churchills.

 

[cvm4]

Monarch Tubo and Mag 46. I haven't really explored this line much. Never had a S/C or the like. No. 2 is okay though

 

[Hot_Sauce]

So far I would say the Mag 46 & the #2.

Have not tried Sir Winston though.

 

[The Prince]

I was not aware Habanos S.A. produced a Sir Winston tubo. Are you sure your not speaking of the Monarchs?

 

[cvm4]

You're right...Edited it...hehe

 

[tripp]

The Mag46 is a great cigar, a classic.

Like what was said earlier, the Sir Winnie is a fantastic experience if you got the time. Which I never do.

 

[Eric]

Monarch Tubo is my only favorite H. Upmann

 

[Jwrussell]

Have not tried anywhere near enough to say. I do like the Mag46s though.

 

[IHT]

i've had a few different sizes of H. Up's, and don't really like 'em all that much...

but, the 2 that i have liked the most are:
#2
Puritos (i know that's not really a hand rolled cigar - but i had to vote for something, i can't stand the mag46).

 

[fitzonelove]

Mag and Sir Winnie; I also love the late, great #4...

 

[Wasch_24]

Mag 46 and Super Corona are the only two I have tried. I have three or four different others in the humi but have not gotten to them yet.

So far I'm 2 for 2. I liked both of the two I have had.

 

[sunivy]

Couple of Mag 46s I've had were just "OK", but I have some Monarcas from '98 waiting in the wings. Had some Petit Upmanns that I surely didn't care for.

 

[Sancho Panza]

No. 4 & Especialles (there are 2 (two) H. Upmann cigars with that name, different sizes)

 

[smokem94]

I have only tried the Mag 46 and the Super Corona. I have a cab of the 46 and only one Super Corona but it was great. The Mag 46 is becoming one of my favorites.

 

[DRL1211]

Mags and Sir Winstons for me. The mags are one of my go to sticks.

 

[Cohiba007]

Mag 46 and Sir Winnie. Cant wait for the Mag 50's

 

[n-tron]

Petite Coronas and #2 for me :yes:

 

[The Prince]

Votes Tallied.

Sir Winston: 5
Super Corona: 3
Magnum 46: 11
Monarcas: 3
No. 2: 3
No. 4: 1
Puritos (?): 1
Especiales: 1
Petit Coronas: 1