What's new

Need some opinions

BrooksW

BoM June '09
Rating - 100%
131   0   0
Joined
Dec 25, 2008
Messages
2,530
Location
Dallas, Texas
Hello all!

So, as you may or may not know, the contest on my blog is coming to an end, and I excited to see who wins :)

However, as I keep putting up reviews, I have noticed that I gravitate towards reviewing fairly rare and HTF sticks, as alot of the ones I smoke are that way...also, I have gotten quite a few emails and comments along the line of "Sounds like a great stick, but not one that I will ever see or find" or the like...

Now, I started the blog for a couple of reasons:

1. I saw that there were very few good photos of the cigars we all like to smoke, and I knew I could rectify that.
2. I enjoy smoking cigars, and have for years, and have been taking notes on cigars as I smoke them for years, but this keeps all of my thoughts in one place.
3. I enjoy camaraderie among cigars smokers...believe me when I say it is NOT the same in my other job, and it is great to get away to totally different group of people and interests.

So, where is all this going?

When I search for, buy and smoke cigars, I am always looking for something that I have not smoked, something different, always trying new things...so when I do find most sticks I have been looking for, I usually buy as many as I can find/afford, knowing that even if I hate them, i can bomb them out or sell them at a later date...

This practice is good sometimes (when I bomb people :) and bad sometimes (when I have to pay!), but it is what it is...

So, here is my question. I have MANY other reviews coming up of htf sticks, and the last thing I want the blog to be is a place for people to go to to read about a stick they will never see...

I also LOVE the idea of giving people something that they cannot find/get for themselves, sharing the love, so to speak...Honestly, that is one of the best things about the cigar community for me, and I want to keep it up....

I am thinking about starting a standard "contest" (although I honestly hate that term) that will be based on what I did for the first one...So, for every review I do, I am thinking about sending one of the same cigar to one person who comments under each post... i.e. if I do a review on, say, a Por Larrañaga Magnifico (which is upcoming), and 18 people comment on the post, then one of them will get sent a Por Larrañaga Magnifico, drawn out of a hat or something...(Obviously, I could not do this with every cigar, since I only get one of a few of them, like the HMR and the like, but the vast majority of them I would be able to)...

What do you think? It will give people a chance to get some cigars they would not ordinarily get, and I get the satisfaction of helping out a BTOL with every post :)

Now, obviously, another factor is to drive people to the site, but since I don't have any advertisers (and refuse to take them on) then it is just for my enjoyment :)

Any thoughts would be appreciated, I truly respect what yall think...

Thanks in advance!

~brooks
 
Rating - 100%
104   0   0
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
5,818
Location
Dallas, Texas
I think that's a GREAT idea Brooks. I, for one, will probably never see a PSD4 reserva, and this would give folks a small glimmer of hope that they may get to try one.

I would continue to stalk your site, if for nothing more that the fantastic pictures!

Anyhow, if you've got the time to do something like that, I think it's a wonderful idea!

:thumbsup:
 

n.olson

Veteran Eccentric
Rating - 100%
67   0   0
Joined
Jul 14, 2009
Messages
1,565
Location
Salem, Or
that is a pretty fantastic idea! that could be a lot of fun on here, where your brothers could add to your review by offering what they thought of your gifted cigar...

fantastic idea.
 

BrooksW

BoM June '09
Rating - 100%
131   0   0
Joined
Dec 25, 2008
Messages
2,530
Location
Dallas, Texas
that is a pretty fantastic idea! that could be a lot of fun on here, where your brothers could add to your review by offering what they thought of your gifted cigar...

fantastic idea.
Hmmm....you know that is not a bad idea either, perhaps get the people who win to write what they thought (a short thing, obviously) and post those...

It is all about the love of the sticks... :hysterica

~brooks
 

Soundwave13

BoM Feb 2010
Rating - 100%
143   0   0
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
4,847
Location
Nazareth, PA
You could throw in some reviews of your favorites (what's burning really good right now, aged smokes) and also do some of your least favorites (that would be entertaining!)...

Love the sight, particularly your honesty about your impressions & opinion - not to mention that the pictures are amazing! Keep up the great work!
 
Rating - 100%
78   0   0
Joined
Oct 13, 2008
Messages
2,631
Location
Ohio
Ok, here is my 2 cents...for what it's worth.

I read the blogs because I think it's fresh and you have the best pictures out there. If you are trying to drum up traffic by offering free sticks on every review that is a different story. I wouldn't want to commit to something that, in the long run, will take a lot of time, effort, and funds (which one day will stop - resulting in downturn and frustration).

Yes, it would be cool to get a chance at some rare sticks, but then again they are out there, i.e walking into a B&M that has AVO 22s on the shelf @ MSRP, or knowing where you can still buy stuff from the late 90s and early 00s. PART of what sets you apart is that YOU are doing things that others aren't... that you can get sticks that others cant... that we get to see rarities burned (I don't want to see another RP Edge review, really!)... hence the package this week...

I like the approach of not caring and wanting to have what others don't... because part of cigars is getting lost in unfathomable amount of details and intricacies that go into every stick (from seed to your devastated mail box).

It's part of the game, it's part of the fun... a lot of BOTLs share, even last stick or sticks they never have had, but you just started Brooks...

The people will come...
The sponsorships will come (if you want it)...

It's only a matter of time!
 
Last edited:

Jfire

BoM 9/9' 9/11' 8/12'
Rating - 100%
391   0   0
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
7,512
Location
Yorkville, IL
I'm going to throw a curve ball in this. And to be honest its just my opinion (if it even matters anymore)
I love to see reviews on sticks. Hell I love this site maybe even to much! I even love to see all the brothers reviews as well "IF THERE ON THIS SITE". I AM TIRED OF SEING. "SEE THE REST ON MY SITE/BLOG" I really give two shits about going to another site and seing a review. It's not why I'm here and it will never be.
Brooks,
If you don't care what others think then review what you want "ON HERE". Why "give away" that same stick.(Unless its to get guys on your site) I guess I'm kinda confused anymore. Don't know if Im just being a dumbass anymore but its just me and my honest opinion. I think it may be time for a break.
B.T.W.
I had a great time at UPDOWN Tabaccco W Diana @ her 75th bday party tonight. "Read more about it at my blog". Jesus Christ guys.
If I'm wrong I'm sorry guys but I'll make no apologies. I'm always here for the brothers and thats it.
Justin
 
Rating - 100%
104   0   0
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
5,818
Location
Dallas, Texas
I'm going to throw a curve ball in this. And to be honest its just my opinion (if it even matters anymore)
I love to see reviews on sticks. Hell I love this site maybe even to much! I even love to see all the brothers reviews as well "IF THERE ON THIS SITE". I AM TIRED OF SEING. "SEE THE REST ON MY SITE/BLOG" I really give two shits about going to another site and seing a review. It's not why I'm here and it will never be.
Brooks,
If you don't care what others think then review what you want "ON HERE". Why "give away" that same stick.(Unless its to get guys on your site) I guess I'm kinda confused anymore. Don't know if Im just being a dumbass anymore but its just me and my honest opinion. I think it may be time for a break.
B.T.W.
I had a great time at UPDOWN Tabaccco W Diana @ her 75th bday party tonight. "Read more about it at my blog". Jesus Christ guys.
If I'm wrong I'm sorry guys but I'll make no apologies. I'm always here for the brothers and thats it.
Justin
Jeezus Justin - Take a valium, a shot of rum, get some rest, and call me tomorrow!! :grin:
 

CWS

<b>Lead Moderator</b>
Staff member
Rating - 100%
227   0   0
Joined
Feb 8, 2006
Messages
17,527
Location
West coast
I'm going to throw a curve ball in this. And to be honest its just my opinion (if it even matters anymore)
I love to see reviews on sticks. Hell I love this site maybe even to much! I even love to see all the brothers reviews as well "IF THERE ON THIS SITE". I AM TIRED OF SEING. "SEE THE REST ON MY SITE/BLOG" I really give two shits about going to another site and seing a review. It's not why I'm here and it will never be.
Brooks,
If you don't care what others think then review what you want "ON HERE". Why "give away" that same stick.(Unless its to get guys on your site) I guess I'm kinda confused anymore. Don't know if Im just being a dumbass anymore but its just me and my honest opinion. I think it may be time for a break.
B.T.W.
I had a great time at UPDOWN Tabaccco W Diana @ her 75th bday party tonight. "Read more about it at my blog". Jesus Christ guys.
If I'm wrong I'm sorry guys but I'll make no apologies. I'm always here for the brothers and thats it.
Justin
In some ways I agree. I love reviews but refuse to be dragged to another site for it. This is my home and this is where I like to get my info. No slam bro. You have a great blog. I just like to read it here.
 

Jfire

BoM 9/9' 9/11' 8/12'
Rating - 100%
391   0   0
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
7,512
Location
Yorkville, IL
Well I didnt see that coming. I seen more of a chat heading my way. But I'm glad we can still talk amongst ourselves.
 

BrooksW

BoM June '09
Rating - 100%
131   0   0
Joined
Dec 25, 2008
Messages
2,530
Location
Dallas, Texas
Ok, here is my 2 cents...for what it's worth.

I read the blogs because I think it's fresh and you have the best pictures out there. If you are trying to drum up traffic by offering free sticks on every review that is a different story. I wouldn't want to commit to something that, in the long run, will take a lot of time, effort, and funds (which one day will stop - resulting in downturn and frustration).

Yes, it would be cool to get a chance at some rare sticks, but then again they are out there, i.e walking into a B&M that has AVO 22s on the shelf @ MSRP, or knowing where you can still buy stuff from the late 90s and early 00s. PART of what sets you apart is that YOU are doing things that others aren't... that you can get sticks that others cant... that we get to see rarities burned (I don't want to see another RP Edge review, really!)... hence the package this week...

I like the approach of not caring and wanting to have what others don't... because part of cigars is getting lost in unfathomable amount of details and intricacies that go into every stick (from seed to your devastated mail box).

It's part of the game, it's part of the fun... a lot of BOTLs share, even last stick or sticks they never have had, but you just started Brooks...

The people will come...
The sponsorships will come (if you want it)...

It's only a matter of time!
Dude, those are some GREAT thoughts, seriously, thanks for that...

I agree with you on most of those thoughts....What if I was to give a stick every once in a while? Like just when I feel like it? Not every stick at all, but when I have some extras...That would still get some people some sticks, and make me happy :)

Also just a note, I am NOT in this for the sponsorships or money at this point...I wanted a place that I could put my thoughts, and I wanted a place that people knew they could go to to get real thoughts (not that other reviews don't mind you, I am not saying that)...

Does that make sense?

~brooks
 

SkinsFanLarry

Craft Beer Addict!
Rating - 100%
78   0   0
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
14,355
Brooksey, What I find interesting about your reviews of HTF sticks is that I actually know the person that's smoking them, even though we haven't met in-person.

That way I have a better understanding of those particular cigars, even if I haven't tried them myself. I'm kinda living the experience of those cigars through you!

It's like the other post on the site now, about C.A. Magazine, the main reason I dislike their review's is that I have no idea who is smoking the cigars and so I don't really care that much about them. With you it's different, you're family.

So in a nutshell, keep doing what you're doing and I will continue to enjoy your reviews and the great pictures.

About the contest idea, that's entirely up to you my friend.
 

Jfire

BoM 9/9' 9/11' 8/12'
Rating - 100%
391   0   0
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
7,512
Location
Yorkville, IL
Well if your here for BOTL then post the review here. I mean J C there are a few and not just you who post almost (51% on/about the blog or sticks pertaining to it) Brooks you may be the exception w tr/ ratings but tonight just "started " my rant. Why come here and start a review and lead us somewhere else. ???????? I know I'm looked at as a J Ass now. But as Gramps said. "Call em how you see em son!"
 

BrooksW

BoM June '09
Rating - 100%
131   0   0
Joined
Dec 25, 2008
Messages
2,530
Location
Dallas, Texas
I'm going to throw a curve ball in this. And to be honest its just my opinion (if it even matters anymore)
I love to see reviews on sticks. Hell I love this site maybe even to much! I even love to see all the brothers reviews as well "IF THERE ON THIS SITE". I AM TIRED OF SEING. "SEE THE REST ON MY SITE/BLOG" I really give two shits about going to another site and seing a review. It's not why I'm here and it will never be.
Brooks,
If you don't care what others think then review what you want "ON HERE". Why "give away" that same stick.(Unless its to get guys on your site) I guess I'm kinda confused anymore. Don't know if Im just being a dumbass anymore but its just me and my honest opinion. I think it may be time for a break.
B.T.W.
I had a great time at UPDOWN Tabaccco W Diana @ her 75th bday party tonight. "Read more about it at my blog". Jesus Christ guys.
If I'm wrong I'm sorry guys but I'll make no apologies. I'm always here for the brothers and thats it.
Justin
Thanks so much for the thoughts Justin :)

Honestly, I have more sticks then I will EVER be able to smoke, and it gives me pleasure to know that I can give someone something that they would not usually be able to get...

Now, I am NOT saying that I would be doing it solely for that reason...I did not put up a blog so that noone would read it, but I think I can get those two to go together..ie, give away some great sticks, and get more people to come to the site to enjoy what I am doing (if they do, of course)...

There ARE alot of blogs out there, and I have a feeling that people are getting "Blog Fatigue", and I am not sure what to do about that...

Does that make sense?

~brooks
 

BrooksW

BoM June '09
Rating - 100%
131   0   0
Joined
Dec 25, 2008
Messages
2,530
Location
Dallas, Texas
Well if your here for BOTL then post the review here. I mean J C there are a few and not just you who post almost (51% on/about the blog or sticks pertaining to it) Brooks you may be the exception w tr/ ratings but tonight just "started " my rant. Why come here and start a review and lead us somewhere else. ???????? I know I'm looked at as a J Ass now. But as Gramps said. "Call em how you see em son!"
No worries :)

I will be honest with you...it takes alot of time to put one of my reviews together... I have to load the photos, fix the photos, write the review, put everything together, etc...

When I come to post here (or any other forum), I basically have to do everything all over again (because the formatting on the sites are different), and I have to do the photos all over again, since I put a photo with my logo on the blog, but I do not want to have my logo all over the pics here...

So, I figured I would split the difference, and post a photo and my basic thoughts on the stick for someone who does not want (or have time) to go to my site, but post a link for those that do...

Hope that helps!

~brooks
 
Top