What's new

Psd#5

Jfire

BoM 9/9' 9/11' 8/12'
Rating - 100%
391   0   0
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
7,511
Location
Yorkville, IL
Temp 72 deg light rain.
11:45 a.m. in garage. Nothing to drink.
Prelight impression: Very soft wrapper, Small to no veins. Light on filler tobacco no soft spots in general, but feels a little light in genral.

Cut with Palio, perfect cut.
Prelight draw: Light wood taste, somewhat loose draw found.
1st 3rd:
Very light tabacco taste, Very light pepper as well. Small woodyness coming thru as well.
Starting to getting a small taste of a Psd4. No barn yard like other ccs brands. Ash is slightly flakey and blackisgh grey.
More sweet tabacco on fisnish(light) More of med pepper on end of 1st 3rd.
2nd 3rd:
Still more sweet flavor coming thru almost a honey taste. Slight uneven burn and a touch up is neccessary. Also more light woodsy flavors as well. Right now even though its light in flavors the finish is extremely long. Draw is still too easy for me. I have to take it very easy on the draw. Retrohaling is eazy as well beacause of the lightness of the smoke.(plenty of smoke though)
Last 3rd:
Not much change or complexity to this smoke at all. I'm starting to think that the psd4 will give this smoke a run for its money any day. I will note that the finish is extremely long it stays almost to each and every puff.
I've also had to retouch or relight several times now. Some light pepper coming back but not much. Sweetness is all but gone as well. I had to let it go out a about the 2inch mark due to it getting hot no matter what I try to do know.
I let it go out. Finish time: 12:50p.m. 1hr 5mins
Final impression:
I have several left of these and will let em sit another 6 months or so. I dont think I would buy this over the PSD4 anytime in the future. The 4s are just smoking to good right now to even consider the thought(also construction is much better as well IMO on the 4s). While it wasnt the worse CC I've had. It didn't seem like even a few yrs are really going to make it that much more of a great cigar. I would be interested to see what others thought to see if maybe I'm off on this cigar.
Thanks for listening.
Justin
 

Benzopyrene

BoM June 08
Rating - 100%
108   0   0
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
2,680
Location
Sugar Land, TX
I actually thought this cigar wasnt bad either, but as you say the 4's are smoking great right now, and there aint no sense in getting away from that. Kinda sucks that its raining here though!
 

smokemifugotem

BoM July '10
Rating - 100%
190   0   1
Joined
Feb 6, 2009
Messages
6,333
Location
Where players go to play
Wow! Great review Justin! I think u hit the nail on the head...just a little more time in the humi will brighten those puppies up! Nice work again on the review...we need another one in a couple months after giving it some time in the humi to see if things changed;) Thanks! Nick
 

Soundwave13

BoM Feb 2010
Rating - 100%
143   0   0
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
4,847
Location
Nazareth, PA
I gotta say that I disagree.

I had this cigar as my first smoke of the day and it was great!!! Best Partagas I've ever had. I'm not the biggest fan of Partagas, lately I've had more of a taste for Bolivar & Trinidads, but this was exceptional.

It started off creamy but developed a richness throughout the cigar that I've never experience with any Parti's. It still had the classic Parti-spice/twang, but also had an extra strenght to it - I thought it was simply a different vitola, but I'm convinced that the blend is 'amped up'.

It burned straight as an arrow with a solid grey ash the whole way. Never re-lit it & nubed it painfully at 1/2". I'll take this anyday over a D-4. Maybe it was just my taste-buds this morning...? I smoked it from about 10-11:15 this am.

Have a Happy Fourth!!!
 
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Joined
Mar 16, 2008
Messages
221
Location
Parana, Brazil
Over the past year and a half I have smoked 4 of these and have been less than impressed by each one. While they are not bad in any sense, they just are .... are ... there! Kept hoping they would break through and bomb me with greatness, but it never happened, ever! It was same-o, same-o; which, again, was not bad, just was not great for the money I put down for them.
Good review, Joliet.
 

Moro

BoM Decembre '08
Rating - 100%
29   0   0
Joined
Aug 12, 2008
Messages
10,387
Location
Mexico City
Thanks for the review, Justin! I'm with ye and Luke: Good, but nothing like the Series D No. 4 which is cheaper, longer and regular production. Though I've some PSD5s aging...we'll see.
 
Top