It's been a few years but I did enjoy Maduro's last time I went. They had a nice selection with okay prices. Don't remember but I think you had to buy your sticks to smoke from them. They serve drinks so maybe you can just buy a few and smoke your own?
+1 for this shop! I can't wait to get back there in September.
Also, I've mentioned in other threads, check out Cigar Aficionado's "Where to smoke" app as well on your phone. It helped me find World Famous Cigar Bar and a few others when I step out of state.
Thanks, guys. Sorry for the late response, but I don't have a lot of time to connect on BOTL these days. I appreciate your responses. I'm heading to Sarasota next week and I'll report back. Cheers!