Sorry bro I didn't see this. I actually live on Staten Island ...Carmine's on Richmond Rd. just actually had a recent Reno and looks amazing! Pretty decent selection of sticks and fair prices, and the people are cool.
Then you have cigar aficion on forest and Richmond ave. across from the precinct. Which prob has the best prices between the B&m's on the island but I'm not to thrilled with the crowed there, they're cool but if your not one of there own you may feel like an outsider.
Then you have cigar vault on page by tottenvile which is primarily where I go. Prices are a little higher, but THE BEST selection you'll get on the entire island hands down. Crowd there is nice, Thursdays are the crowd days.
I know the owners and managers of all the shops and they are all cool peoples. As someone mentioned before, cigar inn is def a place to check out if you have time and try the house stick! Also you have Martinez cigars in the city too if def try out.
Enjoy brother! I'd meet you for a burn but I'm booked today and working doubles tomorrow.
Shoot me a pm if you have any questions. I may be MAYBE haha at cigar vault later not sure.