Trouble deciding please help

[UTvols186]

I recently ordered some trini reyes and some Monte #4. I'm loving the Monte 4. It's starting to get a little colder outside and was looking to pick up a winter smoke, but I can't decide which to order. I'm thinking party shorts or monte #5. Which would you choose and why. Any other suggestions welcome.
Thanks in advance!

 

[icehog3]

RASCC, good right off the truck. I'd buy those, Trini Reyes or San Cristobol El Principes all over the other 2 right now.

 

[SurpriseMVP]

I don't buy Monte due to inconsistency. Not a fan of party shorts, but most love them.
I agree with Tom on his suggestions and will add bcj. I also smoke at least one PL Panatella a week for yard work. Very easy to pitch half way through and not feel guilty about the price.

 

[UTvols186]

I'm not that impressed with the reyes all that much. Maybe they need more rest time. Do the bjc need a lot of rest time? I had a RASS about a week ago and thought that was a fantastic smoke are the RASCC as good?

 

[AlohaStyle]

If you want something to smoke now, I think the H.Upmann Half Corona is hard to beat... they are great little cigars. I would also second the Boli CJ's as I really like them, but they are strong little buggers. I love Party Shorts, but I'm not a fan of fresh Partagas, I definitely prefer them aged a bit. But some people love fresh Partagas, especially people that smoke a lot of NC's and like the spiciness of cigars. Rafael Gonzalez Perlas are a good choice too, can be smoked ROTT.

 

[ENV]

I would say PLPC and PL Panatelas are awesome Also RASS

 

[boltman]

I was trying to decide between Party Shorts and HUHC. On the advice of Dave and StogieNinja I went with the HUHC. I expect them to arrive any day now. BPC are a fantastic short smoke also. Check out the thread "Party Shorts or HUHC", it may help you to decide.

 

[Nacho Daddy]

El Principe.......excellent and priced right. Most consistently good minuto I have ever had..........If you buy them and disagree,contact me..........

Some day they will stop making these and the price will skyrocket on what's left...........

 

[UTvols186]

Ordered a box of the SCDLH El principe.
Thanks for the suggestions.

 

[UTvols186]

Thanks for the recommendations on the SCDLH. What a fantastic smoke.

 

[Cigarth Vader]

I'm a fan of the Petite Edmundo, but all the above should be excellent options

 

[Deadman's Point]

SCDLH is my second to the Party Short, but in front of the RG Perlas if we're talking about 2013-early 2014 box codes on the laters. Since SCDLH is not a major mover, you tend to get the benefit of more age on them at purchase.