What's your take on these? 2003: SLR A & P.P.

[SmokeProper]

What do you think about these 2 cigars?

Saint Luis Rey Serie A 2003

Punch Punch 2003

 

[Fox]

SLR As from that year were excellent. Do not recall the Punch from that time frame.

ETA: As a general rule, '03 was a superb year for many vitolas/marcas. From personal observation, H. Upmann, Juan Lopez, Bolivar, Saint Luis Rey and Montecristo were wonderful. There are always exceptions, but '03 was a good year.

 

[strife]

SLR As from that year were excellent. Do not recall the Punch from that time frame.

ETA: As a general rule, '03 was a superb year for many vitolas/marcas. From personal observation, H. Upmann, Juan Lopez, Bolivar, Saint Luis Rey and Montecristo were wonderful. There are always exceptions, but '03 was a good year.

Great info. That's why I love this place, there's more collective knowledge than I could ever hope to absorb!!

 

[cvm4]

2003 was stellar for a lot of cigars.


Posted via Mobile Device

 

[smokemifugotem]

I am not familiar with the ** from such year...but the slr a's are killer for my $.02! But I also really enjoy all slr sticks. so I might be jaded a bit