Cigar caddy or herfador?

[seeker]

I have a 15 count cigar caddy and I just ordered the 2 count. I understand Otterbox makes these, and I love the Otter. So two questions;
A. I see a lot of the herf brand in ads and on CI. Any body compare the two? Have both?
B. any one use an actual otterbox and add a humidification device? Any difference?

 

[tx_tuff]

I have a couple Herf A Dor cases, I would say they are pretty much the same thing. The Cigar Caddy may be stronger but what the hell are you going to do with it? I have been using my Herf A Dor for years and never had a problem with it and can't think of anything I can do with it that would hurt the cigars.

 

[CWS]

I have a 15 count cigar caddy and I just ordered the 2 count. I understand Otterbox makes these, and I love the Otter. So two questions;
A. I see a lot of the herf brand in ads and on CI. Any body compare the two? Have both?
B. any one use an actual otterbox and add a humidification device? Any difference?

I have almost all otter boxes:

1 2 count
2 5 count
1 15 count
1 50 count
1 iphone case

Absolutely the best.

 

[seeker]

My 2 count has shipped. I'm pretty excited to try and retire the traditional 2 & 3 finger carrier.