Top Rated Cigars of 2012

[Evan]

My fav cigars this past year were:
Headley grange
Lat 52
Illusione Epernay
Viaje WLP candella
Guillermo leon
Tat PCR
Tat Havana VI

 

[ciggy]

Although I thought there were alot of contenders...These are the ones that stood out for me.
BOTL 2012
Liga FFP
Tat TAA 2012
Tat DD
Tat Mummy
Tres Reynas
Cuenca y Blanco

 

[Eric]

I compiled the posts in this thread with a "general" top list (non cuban):

1) Tatuaje TAA '12
2) Headley Grange
3) Four Kicks
4) La Duena
5) Tatuaje Little Monsters (series)
6) Oliva Melanio
7) AF Forbidden X '13'
8) L'atlier 52/54/56
9) Liga Privada T52 Robusto/Toro/FFP
10) Cuenca y Blanco (CyB)
11) Queseda Espana
12) Tatuaje Little Boris
13) Tatuaje Petite Cazadore Reserva
14) MF Federal MF PR Connie
15) Tatuaje Conjonu '12 (mix)
16) La Palina Goldie
17) Room101 Daruma Mutante
18) Liga Privada L40
19) Illusione Epernay
20) LADC Mi Amor Reserva

Runner-ups
* DE BOTL Lancero '12
* Cain F Lancero
* Undercrown Corona Viva
* Tatuaje Mummy
* La Palina Kill Bill II
* Casa Magna Domus Magnus

Notes
* Some are grouped by series
* Tie-breakers decided by me
* A minimum of 4 mentions

 

[Robertsndr68]

Now THAT'S a top 20 list.

 

[javajunkie]

I compiled the posts in this thread with a "general" top list:

1) Tatuaje TAA '12
2) Headley Grange
3) Four Kicks
4) La Duena
5) Tatuaje Little Monsters (series)
6) Oliva Melanio
7) AF Forbidden X '13'
8) L'atlier 52
9) Liga Privada T52 Robusto/Toro/FFP
10) Cuenca y Blanco (CyB)
11) Queseda Espana
12) Tatuaje Little Boris
13) Tatuaje Petite Cazadore Reserva
14) MF Federal MF PR Connie
15) Tatuaje Conjonu '12 (mix)
16) La Palina Goldie
17) Room101 Daruma Mutante
18) Liga Privada L40
19) Illusione Epernay
20) LADC Mi Amor Reserva

Runner-ups
* DE BOTL Lancero '12
* Cain F Lancero
* Undercrown Corona Viva
* Tatuaje Mummy
* La Palina Kill Bill II
* Casa Magna Domus Magnus

Notes
* Some are grouped by series
* Tie-breakers decided by me
* A minimum of 4 mentions

KILLER idea, E! can we call these "the leafies"? and do we get to pass out little banana costume trophies to the manufacturers? o)

seriously, it is cool that you went through and compiled our own consensus list.

 

[bigboy]

That's a pretty great Non-cuban list.

The Tatuaje Avion 12 is missing, have people not had that cigar? I smoked a TAA2012 and that cigar yesterday, I'm starting to like the Avion better than the TAA2012.

 

[fuente~fuente]

Little late here but... No particular order

-LAT-52
-EPM Clase Reserva
-Rodrigo La Fortaleza
-Oliva V Melanio Figurado
-La Duena #5
-RoMa Craft Aquitaine EMH
-CyB Lonsdale
-Illusione Ultra #9
-Room101 Daruma Sucio
-Emilio Serie H Maduro