Can a cigar be too old?

[YodisMatt]

My Industrial Presses are going on somewhere near the 9 year range I believe.

 

[icehog3]

Cohiba Espys...I have a box(s) from every year since 2000

Wow! Nice!! :thumbsup:

 

[Alwayslit]

Yes, storage and vintage are important

 

[rhetorik]

I've had a few cigars that were over 5 years old, mostly CC's, but a few not. I've only had one experience where I felt like the age had hurt it, all the rest seemed to improve in flavor while lessening in strength.

 

[Wanger]

I've had a few cigars that were over 5 years old, mostly CC's, but a few not. I've only had one experience where I felt like the age had hurt it, all the rest seemed to improve in flavor while lessening in strength.

Exact same experience here.