Top 10, can you do it?

[Jwrussell]

So, this just popped into my head and I figured it'd be an interesting question to see answered by everone.

What are the top 10 must-have-in-the-humdior Habanos, IYHO, of course?

10 ONLY!

Here's my stab at it:

Partagas Shorts
Bolivar PC
Montecristo No. 4
Cohiba Robusto
RyJ Exhibicion No. 4
Partagas Serie D No. 4
Juan Lopez Seleccion No. 1
H.U. Magnum 46
Partagas P2
RyJ Churchills


Obviously everyone's will be different due to taste, but what I'm trying to get to is not really your FAVORITE 10 smokes, but 10 classic smokes everyone should have in their humidor (if they have the room :rolling: ). Give it a try, it's harder than I expected it to be. For instance, my list is heavy on robustos, but I just could not imagine a must have list that did not include those three smokes. Off hand I can think of at least a half dozen smokes that should be on the list, but keeping it to 10 I just couldn't do it.

Oh yeah, and the sad part? I currently am missing half my own list (I have at least one each of the other 5)! :crosseyed

 

[Wasch_24]

Hmmmm, 10 classics?

I can easily list my personal top ten...
HdM Des Deuix
HdM du Prince
HdM Epicure #1
Juan Lopez Sel. #1
PSD 4
BBF
PSP2
Boli CG
RAG
ERdM PC


The top 10 classics, IMO, are:
PSD 4
RyJ Ex 4
RyJ Churchill
Cohiba Esplendidos
Cohiba Lancero
Trinidad Fundadore
BBF
Partagas P2 (PSP2)
RASS
PArty Shorts


Funny how we both consider the PSP2 a classic when it is barely over a year old.

 

[Greg]

Trinidad Fundadores
Hoyo DC
Ramon Allones Gigante
Trinidad Reyes
Mag 46
Cohiba Siglo VI
BBF
MC #2
Cuaba Diademas
RASS

 

[DocLogic77]

1) VR Clasico
2) SLR Churchill
3) VR Familiar
4) SLR Series A
5) Trinidad Fundi
6) JL#1
7) Partagas Charlottes
8) Bolivar PC
9) Party Short
10) Mag 46

 

[Jwrussell]

I hear you Todd on the PSP2, but it truly is a classic in the making. No doubt about it.

 

[pharmgator]

boli pc
rass
SC la punta
SLR ser A
Sir winston
punch punch
monte 4
party shorts
vr unicos
bbf

 

[Jwrussell]

7) Partagas Charlottles

Might want to check the box code on those bro'. Not sure I've ever seen a Partagas Charlottles before...sounds good though. :fencing: :stretchgr :razz:

 

[Wasch_24]

Charlottles? :rofl:

 

[DocLogic77]

Wha??? The Charlottles are a classic. You really need to study your hobby. :razz:

You're just jealous because I have the best list.

 

[pdonlin]

Not sure what I would put in a top10 list but I'm tagging this for later.

 

[Wasch_24]

:rofl:

 

[smokem94]

Cohiba Sig VI
Cohiba Robusto
MC#2
Mag46
PSP2
PSD4
JL #1
BBF
Punch RS #11
R&J Ex #4

 

[Poni]

PSD4
RyJ #4
RyJ Churchill
Hoyo Epi #2
Party Shorts
Boli PC
Party Lusi

I may have to come back to this...

 

[Fox]

In no particular order:

Juan Lopez Seleccion #1
Partagas Series D #4
Bolivar Belicosos Finos
H. Upmann Mag 46
Montecristo #2
Cohiba Esplendido
RyJ Churchill A/T
Rafael Gonzalez Lonsdale
Partagas Shorts
Partagas Lusitania

 

[UFGators]

It would be hard to rank these, so here in no particular order

Bolivar Coronas Gigantes
Bolivar Petite Coronas
Bolivar Coronas extras
Montecristo no. 2
Montecristo no. 4 (one out of every three lol)
H Upmann Mag 46
Punch Royal Selection no. 11
Cohiba Esplendidos (5 years old+)
Saint Luis Rey Serie A
Partagas Shorts

 

[CWS]

Monte Cristo #2
H. Upman Mag46
Cohiba Eplendido
HDM Epicure #2
Partagas Serie D #4
Bolivar Belicoso Fino
Punch Punch
Monte #4
Partagas Short
RyJ Churchill

 

[Fox]

After reading all these great lists, I have come to the conclusion that 20 is the minimum for "must haves". . .:hysterica

 

[the nub]

Party Short
Boli PC
VR Familiar
Monte 2
RASS
Party 898
HU Sir Winston
Punch DC
Trinidad Fundadores
Monte A

 

[tedski]

Bolivar Royal Corona
Cohiba Siglo IV
ERdM Choix Supreme
HdM Epicure #2
H Upmann Magnum 46
Monte #2
Partagas Serie D #4
Ramone Allones Specially Selected
RyJ Churchill
Trinidad Fundadores

 

[owljones]

Must Haves:

Boli CJ
H. Upmann 46
ERDM CS
RASS
Cohiba Lancero
PSP2

I could probably live with just these 6.