What's new

DE Undercrown Dogma?

Rating - 100%
90   0   0
Joined
Oct 5, 2010
Messages
1,057
Location
Warren, MI
I'm not so sure about a $10 Undercrown. I enjoy the Corona Viva line and a lot of that has to do with its $7ish MSRP pricing and the ability to grab them for $4 and change on cigar monster.

I usually hate anything larger than a 54 RG but I find box pressed RGs of 56 to be far less offensive and much more comfortable to smoke. Some of my favorite sticks are box pressed but I don't see myself grabbing a bundle of these at this price point.
 

d-boy

Zach Emerson DeBoy
Rating - 100%
80   0   0
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,551
Location
Blue Ridge, GA, USA
I'd try one if it was sent to me but wouldn't consider buying a bundle by any means. I think the secondary band is why everyone's gonna want one. Hell, to be honest I kinda wanted one when I saw it but remembered it's just a band lol.
Just like those that pay hand over fist for a Nobel pig... It was just a secondary band.
I was naive at the time and just wanted it for the complete picture dammit!!! Lol never again. Lmao
haha that wasn't a stab at you brother, I have no clue what you paid!

But watching people go nuts for them when it was an FFP with a second band.
Total thread derail lol but I thought it was funny. I paid $400 for it. Pretty good deal lol right? Jk double msrp for a FFP and I can't believe I did that looking back at it.
 

ENV

@Driven_not_Hidden
Rating - 100%
83   0   0
Joined
Sep 7, 2013
Messages
5,432
Location
NY
J Drew is very good at knowing how to have people overpay for sticks. Hype and rarity. I for one dont mind the UC but they also are not in my top 10 list. They are a good smoke for the price. These IMO are going to be the overpriced rare/gimmicky version to make DE some extra funds on the same blend.

But I do say this... JD if you are reading this. Make an UF-13 Lancero.

Trust me
 
Rating - 100%
165   0   0
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Messages
3,679
Location
Greensboro, NC
[Insert typical hater response here]

;)

Seriously, enough "new" vitolas already. Get back to making the cigars everyone wants instead of marketing more filler sticks into the catalog. I'm not impressed. Now if they came out and said the L40s was finally going to be a true "regular production" cigar and it wouldn't get marked up to 20 dollars by retailers trying to hold onto stock for the wow factor, I'd be excited...
This isn't a filler stick though. It's a limited release for the Cigar Dojo through Smoke Inn. Typically, I don't think of store exclusives as being fillers for their list of cigars. Store exclusives/private labels are meant to give certain retailers a cigar to enhance them, and separate them from other merchants. DE has done this in the past with UF-4. I get that as a cigar smoker you want them to come out with more products that are readily available and not limited, but limited edition cigars do enhance the reputation of the company and creates a buzz and demand that is helpful in the long run. I don't think DE ignores their regular portfolio of cigars to focus on limited edition and store exclusive cigars, but that is just my opinion.
 
Rating - 100%
165   0   0
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Messages
3,679
Location
Greensboro, NC
J Drew is very good at knowing how to have people overpay for sticks. Hype and rarity. I for one dont mind the UC but they also are not in my top 10 list. They are a good smoke for the price. These IMO are going to be the overpriced rare/gimmicky version to make DE some extra funds on the same blend.

But I do say this... JD if you are reading this. Make an UF-13 Lancero.

Trust me
Eddy, the benefit of private label or store exclusive cigars are meant to help the retailer who has exclusive rights to it. Being able to offer something that exclusive gets people to go out of their way to shop at their store. The store often benefits more than the cigar maker, but ultimately it helps the cigar maker improve the relationship between them in the retailer. It's the same reason why Drew Estate is putting a lounge in Corona. It enhances their relationship and rewards the retailer for creating a strong relationship.
 
Rating - 100%
30   0   0
Joined
Oct 27, 2012
Messages
2,184
Location
Orlando, FL
[Insert typical hater response here]

;)

Seriously, enough "new" vitolas already. Get back to making the cigars everyone wants instead of marketing more filler sticks into the catalog. I'm not impressed. Now if they came out and said the L40s was finally going to be a true "regular production" cigar and it wouldn't get marked up to 20 dollars by retailers trying to hold onto stock for the wow factor, I'd be excited...
This isn't a filler stick though. It's a limited release for the Cigar Dojo through Smoke Inn. Typically, I don't think of store exclusives as being fillers for their list of cigars. Store exclusives/private labels are meant to give certain retailers a cigar to enhance them, and separate them from other merchants. DE has done this in the past with UF-4. I get that as a cigar smoker you want them to come out with more products that are readily available and not limited, but limited edition cigars do enhance the reputation of the company and creates a buzz and demand that is helpful in the long run. I don't think DE ignores their regular portfolio of cigars to focus on limited edition and store exclusive cigars, but that is just my opinion.
I get you are in the industry. That's how I'm viewing your reply. I am no stranger to marketing. Call it what you want. Hype is just that. In the end, you have a box pressed UC you paid 3 bucks more for. The double banded pigs mentioned above are worse because there isn't even a change in profile due to the different vitola. There is no reason to hype over it.

I don't think your statement about them neglecting other lines to do these kinds of limited runs is accurate. Man power and resources are limited. If you allocate them somewhere, they can't be used somewhere else. Time and money are finite. I understand there are a limited number of rollers in their employ who can make the Unico cigars. Sounds like money would be well spent training more to be able to make the cigars people are stepping on each other to get at a competitive price point.

I may be wrong, and if someone has some real info and not conjecture then I stand to be corrected. That said, it won't make me want this UC. I'll leave it to the hype beasts ...
 
Rating - 100%
47   0   0
Joined
Nov 13, 2013
Messages
1,743
Location
Wyoming
I started off in this hobby a DE fanboy. I wanted to collect all the LEs and unicos. I would pay any price to have a completed set. And then it clicked. It's a cigar... And I realized I'd rather have a bunch of tats I enjoy and can re supply than a LE DE that I paid more than it's worth and can't get again even if I like it.


I find myself more and more annoyed with DE each time they release another stick instead of working to make the products they already have in their line up more accessible.

The UC is still one of my favorite sticks. But that's because it's easily accessible and is at a OKAY price point for me and my budget. But the UC lancero and the UC box press don't interest me. I wish JD the best and think he's a great guy with a great dream. But id rather spend my money supporting guys like Jon huber and Pete Johnson.

EDIT: Changed DE to UC
 
Last edited:
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
407
I will give it a whirl, fo sho! Been enjoying the Punch Rare El Doble 60x60. at a Not usually a box press guy. But at that size I like.
 

xddco

The Skipper
Rating - 100%
115   0   0
Joined
Mar 28, 2009
Messages
775
Location
Coral Springs, Florida
[Insert typical hater response here]

;)

Seriously, enough "new" vitolas already. Get back to making the cigars everyone wants instead of marketing more filler sticks into the catalog. I'm not impressed. Now if they came out and said the L40s was finally going to be a true "regular production" cigar and it wouldn't get marked up to 20 dollars by retailers trying to hold onto stock for the wow factor, I'd be excited...
This isn't a filler stick though. It's a limited release for the Cigar Dojo through Smoke Inn. Typically, I don't think of store exclusives as being fillers for their list of cigars. Store exclusives/private labels are meant to give certain retailers a cigar to enhance them, and separate them from other merchants. DE has done this in the past with UF-4. I get that as a cigar smoker you want them to come out with more products that are readily available and not limited, but limited edition cigars do enhance the reputation of the company and creates a buzz and demand that is helpful in the long run. I don't think DE ignores their regular portfolio of cigars to focus on limited edition and store exclusive cigars, but that is just my opinion.
You are correct. They make a product and sell it. If it didn't sell, they wouldn't make it. This special stuff is something that they get approached and paid to do, outside of regular production, and I am pretty sure that the DE staff doesn't sit around the pool and dream about what and where the next LE will be. Pete does LE all the time too... it's business. If you don't like it, don't buy it. Somebody else will.
 
Rating - 77.8%
8   2   0
Joined
Feb 23, 2014
Messages
271
The B&M around me sells doble UC for $9 a stick, so the price tag isn't that far off from what I am used to. Naturally, I can get them cheaper off line. From the several things I have already read on this stick, it is based off of the CV blend...but has its own tweaks. So luckily it's not completely more of the same in a different shape. I'll probably be down for a bundle just to show support to the Dojo and the retailer...guess that is just how I roll. UC is not in my top list, but it's not a bad stick in my opinion.

Edit:: I am a huge fan of Pete and Jon as well and would buy their stuff before this one...but this falls in between releases, so I'm safe lol
 

Hoshneer

Drew Estate NotRex
Rating - 100%
96   0   0
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
7,523
Location
Fort Wayne, IN
I started off in this hobby a DE fanboy. I wanted to collect all the LEs and unicos. I would pay any price to have a completed set. And then it clicked. It's a cigar... And I realized I'd rather have a bunch of tats I enjoy and can re supply than a LE DE that I paid more than it's worth and can't get again even if I like it.


I find myself more and more annoyed with DE each time they release another stick instead of working to make the products they already have in their line up more accessible.

The UC is still one of my favorite sticks. But that's because it's easily accessible and is at a OKAY price point for me and my budget. But the DE lancero and the DE box press don't interest me. I wish JD the best and think he's a great guy with a great dream. But id rather spend my money supporting guys like Jon huber and Pete Johnson.
And now it's time to quote you. This is exactly how I started and feel as well more and more lately. The hype is just so much it burns you out quickly.
 

StogieNinja

Derek | BoM June 2014
Rating - 100%
223   0   0
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
6,466
Location
WA
I find myself more and more annoyed with DE each time they release another stick instead of working to make the products they already have in their line up more accessible.
Those aren't mutually exclusive things, as the blends are totally different. If you have plenty of tobacco to make Undercrowns, and not enough tobacco to make more Unicos, you make more Undercrowns. But that doesn't mean you're making less Unicos.

I think the secondary band is why everyone's gonna want one. Hell, to be honest I kinda wanted one when I saw it but remembered it's just a band lol.
Forget the second band, it's the Corona Viva blend in a larger format. If this were a standard toro, I'd seek 'em out to try them. I like the Corona Viva blend a lot better, it just has that extra bit of sparkle to it. It's the box press that makes me shy from these. Well, that and it's $10.
 
Rating - 100%
42   0   0
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
588
Location
Tuscaloosa, AL
I started off in this hobby a DE fanboy. I wanted to collect all the LEs and unicos. I would pay any price to have a completed set. And then it clicked. It's a cigar... And I realized I'd rather have a bunch of tats I enjoy and can re supply than a LE DE that I paid more than it's worth and can't get again even if I like it.

I find myself more and more annoyed with DE each time they release another stick instead of working to make the products they already have in their line up more accessible.

The UC is still one of my favorite sticks. But that's because it's easily accessible and is at a OKAY price point for me and my budget. But the UC lancero and the UC box press don't interest me. I wish JD the best and think he's a great guy with a great dream. But id rather spend my money supporting guys like Jon huber and Pete Johnson.

EDIT: Changed DE to UC

Thank you for posting this. I to started off as a DE fanboy and still am somewhat. I love the LP and Unico line but it is starting to get old having to search for em then pay an inflated price. I just recently started smoking tats and have found them much easier to find, not as jacked up in price, and just as enjoyable.




Forget the second band, it's the Corona Viva blend in a larger format. If this were a standard toro, I'd seek 'em out to try them. I like the Corona Viva blend a lot better, it just has that extra bit of sparkle to it. It's the box press that makes me shy from these. Well, that and it's $10.

Is the UC corona viva a different blend from the other UC's? I have heard yes and no but do not know who is right. Just wondering if you have a definite answer to that.

Also, since the Noble Pig is a FFP with an extra band and no blend change or size change, what would stop people from recreating the band, apply it to a FFP, then jacking up the price? I know that is fucked up and immoral, but just a thought that I had.
 
Rating - 100%
13   0   0
Joined
Sep 20, 2013
Messages
304
I started off in this hobby a DE fanboy. I wanted to collect all the LEs and unicos. I would pay any price to have a completed set. And then it clicked. It's a cigar... And I realized I'd rather have a bunch of tats I enjoy and can re supply than a LE DE that I paid more than it's worth and can't get again even if I like it.

I find myself more and more annoyed with DE each time they release another stick instead of working to make the products they already have in their line up more accessible.

The UC is still one of my favorite sticks. But that's because it's easily accessible and is at a OKAY price point for me and my budget. But the UC lancero and the UC box press don't interest me. I wish JD the best and think he's a great guy with a great dream. But id rather spend my money supporting guys like Jon huber and Pete Johnson.

EDIT: Changed DE to UC

Thank you for posting this. I to started off as a DE fanboy and still am somewhat. I love the LP and Unico line but it is starting to get old having to search for em then pay an inflated price. I just recently started smoking tats and have found them much easier to find, not as jacked up in price, and just as enjoyable.




Forget the second band, it's the Corona Viva blend in a larger format. If this were a standard toro, I'd seek 'em out to try them. I like the Corona Viva blend a lot better, it just has that extra bit of sparkle to it. It's the box press that makes me shy from these. Well, that and it's $10.

Is the UC corona viva a different blend from the other UC's? I have heard yes and no but do not know who is right. Just wondering if you have a definite answer to that.

Quote from this link: http://halfwheel.com/review-undercrown-corona-viva-prerelease

"Steve Saka, president of Drew Estate, described it to halfwheel a few months ago:

The blend has been slightly adjusted to work best in this format and as a result it has been slightly increased in strength while remaining true to the blend’s inherent natural tobacco sweetness and lush earthy core. It is EXCEPTIONAL – I smoked over 50 of these in the last 2 weeks and am disappointed that I have personally depleted my stock.

The Undercrown Corona ¡Viva! uses all of the same tobacco although the proportions are a bit different in regards to visa, seco and ligero."
 
Top