I got to meet the Roycroft artisan for my humi project this morning. His resume and attitude immediately put me at ease. There are roughly a dozen Roycroft Guild master wood craftsmen in the world (most of them here in Western NY). He's got three decades of experience. Some of his clients have travelled from the other side of the country just to have things designed or built. For someone who has yet to construct a humidor, he was extremely knowledgeable and eager to do it right. He was cognizant of the need to design and craft a functional, airtight piece. He knows another master craftsman in our area who has built several humis for clients, so he has him to consult with when necessary. What stunned me was the perfection in all of his display pieces. The joints, quarter-sawn finishes and inlays were
gorgeous. He didn't want to discuss price yet, because his schedule is backed up for 12 months
(not to beat a dead horse, but he's that good). He promised me sketches in three months, which I'll share with the Brothers for added input!
The delay is actually welcome, because I'm probably going to need a little more cash for the finished product. But it's an heirloom, and I'm confident it will be spectacular.
Oh, and based on my wife's input, my gut feeling and the poll above...I've decided to 86 the "BOTL" theme and focus on traditional Roycroft design cues. Thanks for all the advice guys!