Help with Next order -indecisive

[davo]

Tossing up :

Bolivar coronas jnr
Hupman 1/2 cor
Ryj short church
Monte petit 2 or petit Ed

I've smoked the boli 2 , monte 2 and monte 2 petit, ryj short before and enjoyed the boli and the ryj immensely.

I don't have the resource to get singles of the hupmann to try 1st .... Which is making my box choice even more difficult !!!

Interesting to see people's opinions on these 4 cigars are before I pull the trigger !

Cheers lads

 

[StogieNinja]

Try something new. The HUHC are excellent.

 

[MoJo]

I vote for bcjs or huhcs. But you can always host box splits so you can try them out before committing to full boxes

 

[Smoqman]

Mojo's post is spot on.

 

[andysc83]

HUHC or BCJs for sure.

 

[Schlitzinacan]

You might want to base your decision based on smoking time. The RyJ Short Churchills are about an hour smoke for me, the HUHCs take about 25--30 minutes. That being said, I was able to buy the HUHCs in tins of five (bought two) for about $30 each, which I thought would be a good way to try them.

 

[TraderCigarCo.]

HUP!

 

[Senor Perfecto]

I vote Upmann. Anything but Monte petit 2.

 

[SurpriseMVP]

All depends on your taste preference. For me:
BCJ - best bolivar in production
HUHC - good for grilling and short on time.
RyJ SC - I'll preface by saying I keep 15 boxes of RyJ in my stock at all times. I wouldn't even smoke a gifted short churchill
MP2 - I don't buy Monte due to inconsistency, have had a MP2. The one I had was no good, but doesn't mean other would be the same.

 

[davo]

Thx for all the replies fellas. Looks like it's down to 2 : huhc and bcj although a glowing endorsement by surprisemvp on the ryj has thrown a spanner in the works as I enjoyed them too maybe a tad long for my time restraints though ...... Mojo what's the go with hosting box splits have u more info on this for me man ? I'll happily look into this also

Cheers fellas

 

[boltman]

All depends on your taste preference. For me:
BCJ - best bolivar in production
HUHC - good for grilling and short on time.
RyJ SC - I'll preface by saying I keep 15 boxes of RyJ in my stock at all times. I wouldn't even smoke a gifted short churchill
MP2 - I don't buy Monte due to inconsistency, have had a MP2. The one I had was no good, but doesn't mean other would be the same.

Is the Churchill your favorite R&J Mike? And is the Short Churchill that much different than the Churchill? The only experience I have with R&J is the Belicosos (2 boxes) and my tastes have changed in the last 18 months. I don't much care for the Belicosos any more. If I was to have another go at the R&J lineup what would you recommend?

 

[danmdevries]

HUHC all day

 

[hot grits]

Huhc is in my top 3 right now. Absolutely love them. Wish they were a 1/2 inch bigger

 

[SurpriseMVP]

Is the Churchill your favorite R&J Mike? And is the Short Churchill that much different than the Churchill? The only experience I have with R&J is the Belicosos (2 boxes) and my tastes have changed in the last 18 months. I don't much care for the Belicosos any more. If I was to have another go at the R&J lineup what would you recommend?

Ex4
Ex3
Churchill TUBO, DB have not been as good
Mille Fleurs

I don't care much for the others

 

[BMack]

I vote for bcjs or huhcs. But you can always host box splits so you can try them out before committing to full boxes

My vote also and I wouldn't even blink at missing out on the others because these are far better cigars.

 

[davo]

Well I've ordered a 5er mixed ccs .... Huhc , Bol cor jnr , ryj sht ch , Trinidad Reyes just wanted to try a trini lol so see how we go

 

[davo]

here's the little beauties