Have to totally agree on the Hemingway and the Partagas black, I love those blacks. I always keep 6 or more on hand, I love them.I don't think I have any "must buy, everytime" cigars from the b&m, but I do have a few mainstays:
- Tatauje brown labels
- Opus X
- Hemingways
- PAMs
- Partagas Black labels