Diplomatico is tasty. Drinks a lot more like a scotch that I expected but still carries that sweetness of rum, just not overly sweet. Unfortunately I can't get it in the state of WA for some reason. The sample
@Wasz sent me was fantastic and very much appreciated. After researching this I learned that it is a rum blend and is matured in bourbon and scotch casks. I remember getting fruitiness and a hint of candy like flavors but that distinct "scotch" finish.
My wife got me a bottle of the XO for Christmas and yes, there is a difference. I can't say its worth double the price but its nice to have a nice bottle to enjoy.
The 23, when the bottle is first opened, can have a bit of a bite to it. Nothing extreme or really displeasing, just not as smooth as it gets after having been opened and allowed to breath for a few hours. I have learned to open the bottle and leave it on the counter for a few hours and know that it will lose its edge in a few days. This one can be quit harsh on the first pour but the flavors are still there. Once allowed to settle I get chocolate and coffee with a short finish of candied sweetness (I read caramel a lot for this and agree). If not settled add in a bit of bite and a longish lingering finish.
The XO comes right out of the bottle smooth as silk. Similar flavors just mellowed to a palate pleasing level from the get go. This seems to go better with cigars that the 23. I have read reviews that state that it has notes of tobacco. I get a hint of chocolate, fruity sweetness and a vanilla sweet finish with some zest to it. It settles on the back of the palate and lingers for quite some time but does not interrupt the smoking of a cigar.
Id also like to suggest another one for you to try if you can locate it.
Kirk & Sweeny 12 year. Id been meaning to grab a bottle but always ended up just grabbing another bottle of Kaniche (its about $10 cheaper a bottle and literally right next to it) so I just figured I was gonna get to it at some point. I finally was able to sample the K&S at a bar and it was damn tasty. I got honey and vanilla with a smooth medium length finish.