Most of what smoked when i was really new makes me shudder.
Same here, lol - there's the "total noob" phase, and the "I think I know about cigars but haven't discovered BOTL yet" phase, AKA the Gurkha days, both of which featured a ton of awful smokes...
Not a lot from those days that I still reach for regularly, but some that have a special place in my heart and never disappoint when I burn one:
AB Maxx
DPG black
LADC
Oliva O
NC Punch and Hoyo
ETA - my first DPG black was a pepper blasting nic bomb, but a couple years rest and tolerance building turns them into a rather smooth medium-bodied smoke, still thoroughly enjoyable