Welcome from Tennessee!
The shop you're buying at, do they have a large selection of non flavored cigars?
CAO makes a really tasty cigar called the Brazilia you might enjoy. Take it easy if you start feeling a nic buzz though, don't want to get sick in the shop.
If they carry crowned heads, you might try the Luminosa or some of their other lines for different profiles. Tasty sticks.
Another good intro cigar that you can find at about any shop would b a Fuente 8-5-8, see if you like that distinctive Fuente Dominican flavor.
CAO flatheads are really tasty maduros that you can find most places as well.
Also, La Gloria Cubana are a decent well priced maduro you can find in about any shop.
Enjoy the journey man.
Oh, beginner tip, never stab a cigar to put it out, stinks worse that way and makes more mess, just let it rest and it will go out on its own. Oh,
And never lick the wrapper if you're using a shop, or someone else's cutter... Should go without saying, but some people haven't picked up on that being bad form...
