Where do you smoke? Or plan on smoking? I ask because if you plan on smoking in some local shops I would focus on giving them most of your business. If you plan on smoking mainly at home or somewhere else then a lot of online shopping is OK.
Not everybody agrees, but I try to support my local shops as much as possible. They support the customer by being there so I support back.
Welcome from STL - I'm guessing your name is Jason and you're from KC, right? Hit up Outlaw Cigar, you should be able to find Charter Oak and I think they have some Warped there, and they can probably give you some other recommendations as well