The cigar that is your standard to judge all cigars

[oldglory]

This was a powerful, yet smooth and rich tasting cigar . The wrapper was dark, small veined . The draw was excellent even though the construction was "rock hard". There were large volumes of soft blue/white smoke This is a flavor powerhouse, gobs of smoke, perfect draw,fabulous. Despite the massive flavors, this cigar is smooth all the way down to the end:stretchgr:stretchgr.

 

[BrooksW]

Great choice, that would Def be one of mine...

~brooks

 

[n.olson]

after smoking the 4 and the 2, i liked the 2 better. either way, you can't go wrong for this guy to be your yardstick to which everything else is measured. move over monte #2!

 

[Baldanders]

PSD4 is my all time fav

 

[tubaman]

I don't like 'em, you can keep 'em.

 

[cvm4]

I tend to judge cigars based on the flavor profile of the brand. If it deviates from the flavors of that brand then I'm a little disappointed. Granted, you can't do this for every cigar in a marquee.

 

[Patrick B]

I had my second PSD4 a few days ago, and I could easily say all CC's should be judged against it. Wonderful cigar.

 

[oldglory]

I don't like 'em, you can keep 'em.

Then what ones your cigar?

 

[Moro]

I like where yer head's at. :thumbsup:

 

[tubaman]

Then what ones your cigar?

Well, the one cigar that I base all others on is the Upmann Sir Winston. To me that is the most complex cigar around. A Sir Winnie with some age is absolute bliss!!

That or the RyJ Churchill. But that's me. People go ga-ga over PSD4's and that's fine. I'm not saying it's not a good smoke, I just don't happen to like them. It just doesn't fit what I like to smoke. You guys smoke those PSD4's, that leaves more of the other stuff for me!!!

 

[oldglory]

Well, the one cigar that I base all others on is the Upmann Sir Winston. To me that is the most complex cigar around. A Sir Winnie with some age is absolute bliss!!

That or the RyJ Churchill. But that's me. People go ga-ga over PSD4's and that's fine. I'm not saying it's not a good smoke, I just don't happen to like them. It just doesn't fit what I like to smoke. You guys smoke those PSD4's, that leaves more of the other stuff for me!!!

I think I might have to find some of those and give that bad boy a try:stretchgr

 

[Northshore04]

PSD4, PSP2, can't go wrong with either one.

 

[Soundwave13]

For CC I would vote Trinidad Coloniales. Not necessarily the strongest, but subtle, complex, refined components, perfect construction.

For NC I would vote the Tat Black robusto... same reasons.

 

[Cigary43]

I wish my tastes ran to the inexpensive cigars,,,but nooooo. I will continue the search for all cigars that I can find under $4 that taste like a premium smoke.

 

[bigbwalls]

I agree, oldglory.

I'm finding the PSD No. 4 to be one of my favorite cigars -- if not my favorite.

I've got four of them left, and I will cherish each one.

 

[rebeljohn]

Another PSD4 lover...........
I find myself always coming back to these when I want a special smoke....................

 

[Jfire]

Kev, Sir Winston you say heh? I'll have to find 1 of these so called "Sir Winston" to see what the fuss is about.:headroll:
Yeah I found out with even a year there redonkulous!

 

[hdroadglide]

Kev, Sir Winston you say heh? I'll have to find 1 of these so called "Sir Winston" to see what the fuss is about.:headroll:
Yeah I found out with even a year there redonkulous!

i am SHOCKED. SHOCKED i say. are you sure???:sarcastic

 

[CWS]

Gee Kev, Sir Winsrton? That is a new one on me. Sound really good. :innocent:

 

[tubaman]

Gee Kev, Sir Winsrton? That is a new one on me. Sound really good. :innocent:

I know right?