New guy here: What should I try tonight?

[tfb5701]

I've been lurking for about a month or so but just joined up today. I just took an insane midterm today so I'm going to relax with a cigar tonight. Here is a list of what brands I have in the humi at the moment:

Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real
Romeo y Julieta Habana Reserve
Monte Classic
Gurka Park Ave
Indian Tabac Madro
Rocky Patel Connecticut
5 Vegas Gold
Perdomo Lot 826 Slow Aged
La Herencia Cubana
Oliva G Madro
Rocky Patel Vintage 1992
Punch Rare Corojo
A. Fuente Double Chateau
Zino Platinum Scepter Series Grand Master
Excalibur 1066 Dark Knight
Tatuaje Miami
Macanudo Hyde Park
Romeo y Julieta Viejo

I have some other giveaways for moochers that I'm not going to smoke those(store brands, quorum, flor de oliva). Of the cigar brands in my humidor, I have previously smoked:

RyJ Reserva Real- pretty good
Punch Rare Corojo- Liked it a lot
Rocky Patel Vintage 1992- Love it

I'd like to try something new this time. What I seem to like from the cigars I've smoked before are the dark and smooth coco and chocolate flavors. What should I smoke?

 

[JDP]

Withou a doubt you should have the Tat.:applause:

 

[tfb5701]

I thought about trying the tat but I was considering saving that for a special event because I'm a poor college student and its probably my best cigar I have. We shall see. I might consider smoking it

 

[Stew]

Punch Rare Corojo. My Favorite cigar!

 

[tfb5701]

Punch Rare Corojo. My Favorite cigar!

One of mine too. I've only smoked about 14 different cigars but that one and rocky patel vintage 1992 are my favorites. If I can't decide on a new one to smoke, the punch is getting burned

 

[MP928]

I love the Oliva G Madro! Enjoy whatever you smoke!

 

[Angry Bill]

Tat. No doubt!

 

[CaTeacher]

If you decide to wait on the Tat, go with the Dark Knight.

 

[Stew]

One of mine too. I've only smoked about 14 different cigars but that one and rocky patel vintage 1992 are my favorites. If I can't decide on a new one to smoke, the punch is getting burned

Well if we have similar tastes, you will probably like the La Herencia Cubana. Its a great stick with a sweet wood and cedar core with a hint of spice.

 

[tfb5701]

I ended up smoking one of my 5 vegas gold's. Probably one of the first milds I've smoked. I smoked it up to about 2/3rds through and then let it burn out. It was definitely mild to me. I think I've realized I really don't enjoy mild cigars very much. Not too much going on and the flavors weren't really that strong. Nothing like a punch rare corojo, RP 1992, or oliva serie V.

 

[Cole]

I haven't smoked long but that is eaxactly how I was at first. Now I love a good mild cigar.