I love the Tainos, and I have some sw maddies sitting (thanks BigFoot!!), but the regular SWs I've had were a little bland. They were both from the same dealer, and it could have been improper storage. They didn't even taste Tat-like, but like bland toast. I've heard so much good on them, I will have to revisit them from a more trustworthy dealer, my local B&M.
If I hear so many people rating them above Tainos...something had to have been wrong with the two SWs I had. Plus, the SW maddies smell completely different (I know the wrapper is different, but I'm talking night and day) from the regular SWs I bought...I bought them from an online retailer, so who knows? SW time it is.