For me it was the T52. I found it very unbalanced and unpredictable. I'd get little pockets of flavor now and then, but most of the time I got nothing. Granted, I only smoked 1 and it was fresh out of the box. I'll probably give it the benefit of the doubt and try another just to see if I got a bad stick from the B&M. But the first impressions were not favorable at all.
In the bargain catagory, it has to be the Arganese Blend of the Cugine. The Alec Bradley blend was pretty tasty but when he moved over to using Arganese as the blender the quality of the stick just tanked.
The third was a house blend that a local vineyard had made for them called Vineyard 48. When I saw them in the case, they looked like a hidden treasure. So much plume it was like a cigar rolled in sugar (and no, it wasn't mold). The sticks were still oily and smelled realy good....up until I lit it. It was like smoking grass clippings from a compost pile. I was VERY disappointed because apparently the vineyard knew HOW to care for cigars judging by the amount of plume on them. Too bad all that plume was wasted on something I wouldn't even call a dog rocket out of giving dog rockets a bad name. Oh...and the wine sucked too!
