SmokingStogie - Top 10

[MU Mike]

I love Brooks' site and the work he puts into his reviews, and with his top 10 list on the heels of CA's, let's be the peanut gallery on the SmokingStogie Top 10 list as well.

10. Illusione Singulare
9. E.P. Carillo Short Run
8. Cain F Lancero
7. Tatuaje Petit Cazzy Reserva
6. 601 RPM EL 2010

Loved the Short Run (especially if you factor in value); liked (but didn't love) the Petite Cazzy Reserva; haven't tried the Cain or 601; and didn't care for the Illusione Singulare (bland).

What say you?

 

[L8A]

OHHHHHH much better list i think.

 

[danthebugman]

It'll be interesting to see how an "average" guys list compares to the "elite" list.

Dan

 

[Fourtotheflush]

Ive only had the Illusione and thought it was OK.
Quite dry if I remember, but it could have been the day.

But from what I hear all things Cain are lousy!

 

[gentimmy]

I've really enjoyed Cain F's and Habanos...can't wait to try a lancero.

 

[BrooksW]

Ive only had the Illusione and thought it was OK.
Quite dry if I remember, but it could have been the day.

But from what I hear all things Cain are lousy!

The Cain F Lancero is MILES above anything else in the line, IMHO...not even on the same plane of existence

Sadly, it is an event only release at the moment (like the Tat Black Robusto was, you can only get them when you go to events and buy boxes etc)...

~brooks

 

[jayro75]

The short run is excellent. I enjoyed the Petit Cazzy when I first bought my cab but am finding myself liking them less and less each time I smoke them. I really enjoyed the Singulare and found it very flavorful but can understand how the mild body can throw people off. Haven't smoked the other 2 but have been told by some people whose taste I trust the Cain Lancero is fantastic.

 

[srduggins]

I love Brooks' site and the work he puts into his reviews, and with his top 10 list on the heels of CA's, let's be the peanut gallery on the SmokingStogie Top 10 list as well.

10. Illusione Singulare
9. E.P. Carillo Short Run
8. Cain F Lancero
7. Tatuaje Petit Cazzy Reserva
6. 601 RPM EL 2010

Loved the Short Run (especially if you factor in value); liked (but didn't love) the Petite Cazzy Reserva; haven't tried the Cain or 601; and didn't care for the Illusione Singulare (bland).

What say you?

Scary as I agree with you completely. :robosmile

 

[PLUSH]

Hmm, maybe Brooks should do a contest to win one of each of his Top 10.


just saying. :devilhead

 

[ericdriscoll]

The Cain F Lancero is MILES above anything else in the line, IMHO...not even on the same plane of existence

Sadly, it is an event only release at the moment (like the Tat Black Robusto was, you can only get them when you go to events and buy boxes etc)...

~brooks

The Cain F lance I have been looking to try. The Tat black robos have smoked many. Anyone want to do a trade for a Cain F for a Tat robo LMK. Enjoy the Singular very much and haven't tried the EPC 2010 yet. The others I dug but I've heard very good things about the 2010.

 

[thegoldenmackid]

I've heard rumors of what will be one and two...

Glad someone is going to give Gurkha some love...

 

[itallushrt]

EPC Short run is actually my #1 or #2. Loved the Singulare and the Tat PCR. I haven't had the other 2.

 

[SkinsFanLarry]

I strongly agree with 4 of the 5....and the only reason I can't agree on all five is that I have yet to try the 601.

Very nice list so far Brooksie! :thumbsup:

 

[BrooksW]

$5-#1 are up

~brooks

 

[PLUSH]

$5-#1 are up

~brooks

WHOHOOOOOOOOOOO:awholelot

 

[bigbwalls]

Great pick for Number 1, Brooks.

 

[iCraig]

Thanks for the list Brooks. Gonna be hunting down the ones I haven't tried. :thumbsup:

 

[Thegreekone]

Great list, Brooks!


Yet another job, well done!

 

[MU Mike]

No Fuentes???

Really???

:glassesgr

 

[gardizzle]

great list Brooks. Really enjoy your site. Looking forward to steve and your reviews in 2011.