H Upmann Mag 48 LE09 vs. HDM EE

[ninjafox99]

I only have enough cash for one or the other (not both). your thoughts are much appreciated.

 

[Soundwave13]

HDM EE for me. The Mag 48 is good, but the the greater value, taste & smoke time is with the EE.

 

[cyclops454]

HDM EE for me. The Mag 48 is good, but the the greater value, taste & smoke time is with the EE.

Yeah it's a tough call for me because I've enjoyed both. From a value standpoint I agree the EE is better but strictly for taste I give the Mag 48 the edge. Of course the Mag 46 and H Upmann PC are some of my favorites so I guess my palate is a little bit bias towards H Upmanns in general.

 

[ahbroody]

Mag 48 for me all day.

 

[agentdaffy007]

split box.

 

[Fox]

EE. . .Love Upmanns, but the Mag 48 is not among my favorites.

 

[Bsneed51]

Mag 46s. :laugh:

I like the H. Upmann profile better than HdM, but I'm not crazy about the Mag 48s.

 

[BEN(SWEDEN)]

HDM EE for me. The Mag 48 is good, but the the greater value, taste & smoke time is with the EE.

I agree

 

[grateful1]

It's all in what you like. These are completly different.

I enjoy the 48 and am having trouble letting them sit.

The EE...not so much. But then again, it's all in your taste.

Good luck.

 

[Angry Bill]

I think someone made a great suggestion. DO a box split on each.. Im sure you can find a willing accomplice. I actually liked the 48 better than the EE, but both are smoking well.

 

[jwintosh]

loved the 48! haven't had the ee.

 

[Hot_Sauce]

loved the 48! haven't had the ee.

Me too. Sounds like I need to give the Hoyo EE a try.






I heard that these cigars have a rich flavor to them. Has that been you guys experiences?

 

[njstone]

I want to try both

 

[Zen Cigar Man]

love the ee's. smoking good now. will be awesome in a few.

 

[Fox]

Me too. Sounds like I need to give the Hoyo EE a try.

I heard that these cigars have a rich flavor to them. Has that been you guys experiences?

It certainly has been mine. I got gifted some a year or so back and was very impressed. I had never been a great HdM fan except for the Des Dieux, but I found the EE to be rich and complex. I bought a couple of SLBs and they have been stellar. It is a relatively mild cigar. I typically lean towards much stronger smokes, but the flavor in these is simply wonderful and hard to resist.

 

[ninjafox99]

Thank you for all your responses. Looks like the majority voted for the Mag, but a very generous botl offered a split on some EE's, so i'll give those a shot. I'll probably try the Mag in a couple months (too many LE Tatuajes to buy).