The Fifty Best Cigars!?

[drubcurtis]

I never put too much stake in these lists (CA especially), the subjective component is too strong of an overriding factor...

 

[Racmanjr]

I dont feel right disagreeing as I havent really smoked many on that list, but the bolivar (third down, first page) belongs there IMO. That stick knocked me on my ass for hours, it was absolutely amazing.

 

[MaytagMan]

I dont feel right disagreeing as I havent really smoked many on that list, but the bolivar (third down, first page) belongs there IMO. That stick knocked me on my ass for hours, it was absolutely amazing.

You should absolutely feel right disagreeing with the list. Your palate is your palate, and nobody can tell you what tastes good to you.

The BBF is indeed a classic cigar, though not my favorite by a long shot. Does that make it a bad cigar? Not at all... it just doesn't fit my ideal flavor profile at the moment. (But that does change from time to time)

On the other hand... why we are giving a thread to a sire that ranks Puros Indios, AB Pryme, Cusano C10, and CAO in a top 50 anything is beyond me... :devil:

 

[JDog]

On the other hand... why we are giving a thread to a sire that ranks Puros Indios, AB Pryme, Cusano C10, and CAO in a top 50 anything is beyond me... :devil:

I agree... I've smoked all of those and I'm scratching my head how they got there. I still have a few Cusano C10s in my humidor if anyone wants to try one.

 

[funkejj]

I bet there are 15 decent smokes on there. But I am appalled they don't have my go to stick listed.Fuente curly head is where it is at!!!!

 

[Cigar Cowboy]

best 50 cigars

I disagree

 

[cmhicksusmc]

That's ludicrous