Similar situation- Buddy gave me a 2008 BBF and it blew me away. Had that unique Cuban spice to it, medium body, perfect burn, beautiful ash and incredible aroma. After smoking it I have bought a sampler of Petite Coronas, a box of Boli Royal Coronas, a box of Partagas 8-9-8's and just ordered a box of RyJ Cazadores. However, while my Cuban's get a bit of age on them I'll stick to my NC's and the petite coronas. I smoked a Boli Royal Corona and while it was a great smoke, it wasn't near that same level the BBF was. For right now, I smoke roughly 80% NC, 20% CC until my stash grows a bit. I can't ever see myself giving up those Tat's, Liga's, Illusiones, etc. There are times when a simple CAO Brazilia or Man O War just hits it off for me, and that's why I love having variety within my humidor.