My favorite is Puppets, but Kill em All is a close second. I will have to say, Reload was not a bad album, there are few songs off that album that even though are in no comparison to KEA, RTL, MOP or AJFA, they are more along the lines of that time period, than the Black Album or any of the other garbage they have put out. Garage INC is a great album and I love their take on the covers, but its still a cover album by a great cover band. I will say however, I do love S&M, I find myself listening to it on long road trips, I love listening to the crowd as they realize what song is about to start playing after the orchestras intro.