Grats sir! My first box purchase was ACID Kuba Kubas (this was primarily for a friends bachelor party). I don't really like them anymore though. I do, however like a few of the more nontraditional and traditional Drew Estates blends, especially the Liga line. My second box purchase was Drew Estate Natural Root. Fantastic blend.
Beyond that, I've snagged a box of RP Olde World Reserve Maduro Lanceros and a box of RP 1961 Coronas. I'm relatively new (just a year) to the whole cigar thing myself, but I've been enjoying these more budget-friendly sticks. Great med-full smokes that are packed with flavor.