If you haven't tried them yet, I would highly recommend Highland Park 12 and The Balvenie Doublewood 12. Although I think the Balvenie is the best one I've had, the HP 12 is the best value for the money @ $40 a 5th.
Oddly enough, even though I do enjoy a good scotch I've yet to find a good pairing with a cigar. I guess I'll just stick to by bourbon and rum!:stretchgr
Oh, and go team college Brothers! (I think Moro started a college group for BOTL, you should ask him about it!)