What is there to keep track of? They are leaves, rolled up, that we light on fire--after we pay good money for them.
I suppose if I ever had any intention of selling a cigar out of my stash, I'd probably keep track just to keep the re-sale value high. But I smoke or give away everything that hits the humidor. Honestly, I've been smoking long enough that I know what I like and what my go-to cigars are. It's a fairly short list and I've had so many boxes of all of them, it's not worth doing gymnastics to remember the 27,248th DPG Blue I've smoked. For stuff that's special, high dollar, or one-off's, they have their own drawer.
I suppose if I ever had any intention of selling a cigar out of my stash, I'd probably keep track just to keep the re-sale value high. But I smoke or give away everything that hits the humidor. Honestly, I've been smoking long enough that I know what I like and what my go-to cigars are. It's a fairly short list and I've had so many boxes of all of them, it's not worth doing gymnastics to remember the 27,248th DPG Blue I've smoked. For stuff that's special, high dollar, or one-off's, they have their own drawer.