Since your $75 is a store credit, a lot of these suggestions won't work at all for you, obviously. I'd dig around and just pick whatever sounded familiar that you hadn't tried. I picked up a Curivari because I kept hearing about them, and loved em. Maybe a higher end Padron? A fancy tatuaje? Find a thread here about a size you like, and read the suggestions, and see what sounds good to you. We have threads on small cigars, bigger ones, Nicaraguan ones.