Funny story!
When I worked at a B&M in Austin, we had a regular who was a cosmetic chemist. make up, creams, and perfumes. People all the time ask him what is the best cologne/perfume? He would always say that it greatly depends on the person. How oily your skin is, the composition of that oil, how prone to sweating you are and even what you've eaten and drank in the last several days. So one formula that works amazing for one person can be disastrous for another.