Looking for some direction for the collection

[BMack]

Based on what you have and seem to like, I'd consider some of my favorites:
Jaime Garcia RE LE 2011
Quesada Oktoberfest
Tatuaje TAA

all three are mind-blowingly good.

 

[ilikefishes]

Good luck finding the TAA's at a fair price. Just sayin'!

 

[Knickerbocker]

Stick to NCs for now. Too many amazing ones out there to try still.

I once thought the same thing as you, but give CC's a try! I was gifted a few CC's, then ended up buying a few boxes on my own and my mind was completely blown. I do not think I have smoked a NC in 3 months.

 

[BMack]

Good luck finding the TAA's at a fair price. Just sayin'!

I've actually seen them for very reasonable prices. I bet some are still at less popular retailers, at least there were a month ago. I'd say buy them all if you can!

Actually, the Oktoberfest is probably the rarest of the ones I posted. That one may take some searching for but it's worth it.

 

[Dave]

Concur on the Illusione recommendations. I, for one, much prefer the core line over the Epernays. (I also am not too fond of the maduro - but then I don't like too many San Andres-wrapped cigars.)

I don't see any Litto stuff listed. I trust you've tried some. Chisel or chiselito maduro may be right in your wheelhouse - one of the small batches, perhaps -- or even the cheroot -- SB and cheroots tend to be a little overpriced to me, but never fail to impress