Murray got yanked for a game and had multiple poor games, he only stole one game on his own. The most impressive part if his run was his being a rookie.
I thought Sid played a very strong 2 way game, didn't do any crying (unlike people whining to the media that Sid cheats at faceoffs

) was a good leader and solid stats.
If there's an argument to be made it's for Kessel, his stat line was stronger, but I don't think the Canadian media could swallow voting for him after ragging the dog shit out of him for years. I kinda smelled this coming as every time Sid did something halfway right the media was all over it, it just felt like they wanted to get him the a CS that he didn't have yet. I don't think he was a poor choice though, it wasn't like there was anyone head and shoulders above anyone else.