Pudgy Face
Would be my least favorite out of the box if not for the Tiff, an overly large rg that mutes the wrapper + combustion issues = disappointment. And I love me some San Andres. I would have taken the gauge down to 52 and moved the "Face" up an inch, would have made for a more interesting cigar and helped to take the bite out of that last 1/3.
2c-
I really enjoyed smoking through the Pudgy's, it was pretty fun and Id recommend grabbing a box if you havent. But unless I can find them for $60 there are just too many bummers in there to make grabbing another one worth while.
I still have a Mum, Jas and Chuck, look forward to burning them with you guys again next year, Happy Halloween!