As the board's official place-name Nazi, welcome from Southern California...
San Diego, to be precise.
Good luck with your issue. The only thing I can think of is
1) your tastes are changing,
2) your cigars are all going through "the sickness" together which would strange,
3) or maybe you just need more cedar in the new wine fridge - maybe your humidor did a great job imparting cedar notes into your sticks, and your tastes are so calibrated to that "balance", that everything tastes "different" now that you have moved into a new environment.