I'm new too and agree with what most brothers OTL on here recommend. Flor de las Antillas is one of the best out right now, Olivia V Pedromo both nice with good complexity.
I thought the AF Hemingway was over-rated, still good but maybe too woody/leathery for me. If you have access to a good B&M, they may be able to keep a purchase record for you.
If so, but one of many sticks and experiment. I walked by Carillo's INCH line and Chupa Cabra, but they recommended based on my prior purchases and likes and was a solid for me.
Also, try CigarBoss phone app, while still buggy it's an easy way of giving your smokes a quick 1-5 star rating.