This is intresting, our dear friend Jim is lobbying hard for the 2008 and I have asked around, smoked but nothing from 2008 in the regular produktion tastes better then usual to me or ANYONE I have asked, I know Rob from FOH says some stuff from late 2008 is roving to be good but I just dont see it and neither does anyone I know. But 2008 Partagas 898 has been bad the 2 boxes I have had, and the 10-15 my buddies has tryed has pretty much been below standard.
Wish I got my hand on one of the 2008 boxes you guys have to be able to try one good from 2008.
I've had some great Bolivars from '07, and a number of great sticks from '08 from different marcas, but I don't smoke nearly as many Habanos as you. Most people seem I've heard seem to agree on a couple things, though:
1) Cuban tobacco from 2006 to the present has been, in general, very good
2) Habanos from 2006 onwards have been more approachable when young than in years past (this this effects longer aging, I don't know)
3) 2010 was a stellar year for Cuban tobacco in general and many Habanos lines
If I had the ability, I'd get vintage 2010 boxes of all my favorites, as I"m sure they'll be very good in years to come. I've had a few that I think are already good now (Party Short, Boli RC, R&J SC), and I've never before enjoyed fresh Habanos.