The most elegant cigar you've ever smoked?

[SDShark]

A new stick on the market, but the "Flor de Las Antillas" by My Father has been my most elegant cigar to date. The taste of smooth butter with pepper did it for me.

 

[sonarman]

La Tribu. Fruity sweetness, cream, and a spice that you feel in your belly.

 

[whodeeni]

I think I will smoke one out on the course today. I am playing Sterling Hills out in Camarillo, CA

Gonna try this one out today!

 

[pabloj671]

Davi Chateau Margaux or CGR.... hard to pick one...

 

[ciggy]

Off the top of my head...Trinidad Extra Rob, Padron 85th, and the LFD SB IV

 

[Fia]

I would have to say an Epernay and a Cohiba robusto that was gifted to me once (although others ones I have had since were not as good).

 

[hdroadglide]

Davi Chateau Margaux or CGR.... hard to pick one...

Gotta agree. Had an old davi, and a cgr that I would call elegant

 

[HarleyMark13]

Pre-embargo Pinar Del Rio. Can't recall the size but damn was it tasty

 

[Martin3203]

Partagas 160 Major

 

[pbear1973]

For me it's the Cohiba Siglo I. Rich creamy smoke, though relatively mild. I'm also fond of short cigars because I don't usually have over an hour to "burn". Haha.

 

[Clint]

Saint Luis Rey Prominente (double corona)

 

[whodeeni]

Oh...... just noticed Sticks&Ash revived this month-and-a-half old thread....... so I'm guessing you already gave him whatever you decided on.

I did, (gave him the Phantom) but we can still get together for a smoke if you like Brotha. Sending you a PM!

 

[carolinacigar]

The Illusione Epernay le Elegance. I know it's a mouthful, but it is elegant and sublime- the info on it says it was created to accompany fine French Champagne.

 

[PhobicSquirrel]

I may get a lot of flac on this but I really do enjoy the gurkha art decos. I don't smoke them that often and what little I have left I hope they keep tasting great. I also enjoy the cohiba behike, though I've only had one. I need a box.

 

[strife]

Lets not forget any of the Cabaiguan naturals.

 

[mgravito]

I gotta say, I think the most elegant cigar I've smoke is the Padron 80th. It hits every check. Shape, band, construction, wrapper color. Oh, by the way: It tastes effing amazing.

 

[MarkJr]

For me it's the Cohiba Siglo I. Rich creamy smoke, though relatively mild. I'm also fond of short cigars because I don't usually have over an hour to "burn". Haha.

Good choice, I would go with montecristo #1

 

[bballbaby]

the old AVO 85th was pretty creamy.
I second or third the Epernay singulare
the last PSD4 from 2007 i smoked was absolutely fanstastic.
aged sir winstons for sure
as well as aged (4-5years) RyJ short churchills, which happens to be my favorite cigar

 

[bballbaby]

Lets not forget any of the Cabaiguan naturals.

THat's a fair statement indeed

 

[CaTeacher]

Davidoff Diadema Fina