Top 10 Cigars

[icehog3]

Partagas 898
H. Upmann Mag 50
Cohiba Robusto
Bolivar Royal Corona
El Rey del Mundo Grandes de Espana
Montecristo #2
Por Larranaga Montecarlo
H. Upmann Sir Winston
Romeo y Julieta Cazadores
Partagas Short
Bolivar Petite Corona
Ramon Allones Short Club Corona

 

[xddco]

In no particular order, but sticking to relatively available/affordable smokes (ie; no EdA, BBMF, LFD Salomone type smokes..)
Tatuaje Verocru West Side
Tatuaje SW Maduro
Illusione 88 or MJ12
Cohiba Siglo VI
Padron Anni Maduro 1926 #2
Opus X Power Ranger (xxx)
Montecristo #2
LFD Diez Chisel
LFD FP
Cabaiguan Guapo Maduro

Others could easily move in and out of that list....

 

[El Baton]

In no particular order...

Tatuaje Black
Padron 1926
RASS
Tatuaje Conujo
LFD Chisel (Double Maduro)
Lito Chisel
Padron 80th Maduro
Tatuaje Regios
San Cristobal Classico
Oliva V

 

[SkinsFanLarry]

1. Master Blend Robusto/Torpedo (The Original)
2. AVO Limited Edition 05
3. PSDN4

4. Tatuaje CS Unicos (My first Tat and better than a Monte No.2 to me!)
5. Illusione ECCJ
6. Viaje Platino Lancero
7. Cabaiguan Guapos 46
8. Illusione Epernay Le Grande
9. Illusione MK
10. Don Pepin Series JJ Selectos

11. Ambos Mundos Robusto No.2
12. Don Pepin Blue Label Invictos
13. Cruzado Domenicos
14. Tatuaje Black
15. Don Pepin My Father No.4 Lancero

 

[BigFoot]

Tat East Coast
Tat Noella Reserve
Tat 2003
Tat 2009
Montecristo Edmundo
Montecristo 3
Pepin CC 1979
Illusione cg4
Tat SW Reserva Mad
DPG ERH corona

 

[smokemifugotem]

This is a tough one!
Tat Black
Tat Reserva SW
LFD Coronado Maduro
El Truf Lanc
Tat Frank
SLR...any
Tat Vera...either
Cab Guap Maddy
Illusion MJ12
Punch Punch

Good thread!

 

[hdroadglide]

haven't had my favorite yet!
hard to pick because if you eliminate those that are htf and might never get again, it changes the list. e.g. tat black jar, tat frank, bbmf, opus maduro, don carlos lancero would have been there.
so shorter available list (at least somewhere in the world) would include
tat reserva noella
tat reserva regio
tat taino
sir winnie
mag 50
psd 4

 

[Gordy]

Partagas Culebra
Tat Frank
H.upman Magnum 50
La Aroma de cuba petite corona
Partagas Serie D #4
tat black
Cohiba Siglo VI
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero
tatuaje regios
davidoff no. 1

 

[blooz4u]

Tatuaje Verocu #1 Westie
Tatuaje Porkchop
Tatuaje Noella Reserva
Boli Belicoso Finos
Illusione MK
Tatuaje Black
PDS4
Rass
Tatuaje SW
Tatuaje Verocu #9
Cohiba Robusto

 

[Zen Cigar Man]

10. Cohiba Siglo VI (2006)
9. AVO LE 09 Companero (2009)
8. AVO 22 LE European Release (2002)
7. Partagas Lusitania (2006)
6. Seleccione Robusto (2002) – A nice little 5 pack of specially blended robustos. One each of Montecristo, HdM, Cohiba, Partagas and RyJ. Couldn’t pick just one...
5. Padron 1926 Anniversary 80 Years
4. Davidoff Vintage 2000 Panetela Extra (2003)
3. Fuente Fuente Opus X Perfexcion A (1999)
2. Partagas Serie P No. 2 (2005)
1. AVO LE 5 (2005)

Honorable Mention-Davidoff Royal Salamone

 

[Electric Sheep]

Damn there's a lot of NCs on these lists!

 

[BrooksW]

Always changing...

* Tatuaje SW Reserva Maduro
* Partagas 8-9-8V '98
* Padron 1964 Imperial (Natural)
* Casa Fuente- Pyramid#2
* Cohiba Siglo IV '08
* Tatuaje Black Label (Jar Release)
* Partagás Serie D No. 4 Reserva
* A. Fuente Work of Art Maduro '99
* Tatuaje Noella Reserva (Oringinal Release)
* Montecristo No.2

 

[jjflynn3]

in no order...
PSD 4
Monte petit edmundo
Tat Black
Illusione cg4
Fuente anejo 50
Tat Verocu 1
Tat Verocu 2
RASS
Fuente Work of Art maduro
Padron 1964 Principe maduro

 

[gibbleguts]

Sancho Panza Belicoso
PSD4 Reserva
Opus Power Ranger
Por Laranaga Robusto De Laranaga
Trinidad Reyes
RASCC
Montecristo Dunhill Selection #3
Anejo 77
OR Noella reserva
Siglo VI Gran Reserva

 

[cashedash]

This thread is perfect for a newbie looking to sample some sticks!

You beat me to it.

 

[Danilo]

Short story
Illusione MK
Tatuaje noella reserve
Opus X (most sizes)
monte #2 (CC)
Fuente anejo shark (all 3 I had where great)
illusione 68

that's what I can have in my favorites list for now... I'm still quite new to this after all...

 

[Northshore04]

ok. I'll play. In no particular order. . .

Tat J21
Tat Black
Padron 1926
Partagas PSD4
Partagas Lusitania
Partagas 898v
Partagas PSP2
Illusione CG4
Montecristo #2
Bolivar BBF

 

[Hot_Sauce]

In no particular order

Partaga 898V
Partaga Lonsdale
Bolivar Corona Extras
H. Upmann Sir Winston
Punch Super Selection No.1
Vega Robaina Classico
Partagas Serie Du Conniseur No.1
Punch Super Selection No.2
Bolivar Belicoso Fino (03 and older)
Saint Louis Rey Corona

 

[mav_sd]

No particular order:

Padron 1964
Joya De Nicaragua Antano
Ashton ESG
Alec Bradley Tempus
Rocky Patel Decade
Drew Estate Liga Privada #9
Arturo Fuente Hemmingway Best Seller
Oliva V
Opus X
Tat Noellas

Great idea... looking forward to what we find out!

 

[Mast3r_Shake]

1. 601 Red Habano Robusto
2. Man O' War Ruination Belicoso
3. Man O' War Corona
4. Five Vegas Cask Strength II
5. Padilla Signature 1932 Toro
6. La Herencia Cubana Robusto
7. Don Pepin Garcia Blue Robusto
8. 601 Green Oscuro Robusto
9. La Aurora 1495 Robusto
10. Alec Bradley Tempus Robusto

I made this list for ones I can smoke daily, so basically sticks I can get easily for <$6 at least. I don't think I have smoked enough premiums to come up with lists like some of you.

I would add the Liga Privada #9, Tat J21, and Cabaiguan Maduro if we start talking no price limit.