I would choose the $20 lighter. If it really is the same lighter, sold for $5, that's only because at some point during production it failed a QC check. Some companies will take the lesser quality products and sell them cheaper w/out the brand name. So now for $5 you have a $20 lighter with a possible defect and no warranty to protect you when that defect rears its ugly head. Like I said in my earlier post, my time and piece of mind are worth more than the $15 extra it would cost to get a product that was good enough to put the company's name on it.here is my point. you can buy a no name lighter for $5, or you can buy that same lighter with a brand name stamped on it for $20. No guarantee with the no name lighter, lifetime warranty with the name brand. still the same lighter. which do you want?